竹島問題の歴史

15.7.08

日本語インデックス(Index of Posts on Dokdo-or-Takeshima?)

日本語インデックス(Index in Japanese)

Q & A (よくある質問)......韓国側の地図/文献......日本側の地図/文献
..
西洋の地図/文献........用語集..... リンク集......N新聞記事等

Occidentalismでの投稿記事インデックス  竹島問題の歴史


日本語の投稿記事(年代順)(Articles in Japanese)

1618年 - 幕府の「渡航許可書」

1656年 - 柳馨遠 『輿地志』 (「東国興地志」巻之七 江原道 蔚珍)

1693-1703年 - 朴世堂『西渓雑録』(張漢相「蔚陵島事蹟」)

1693-1703年 朴世堂『西渓雑録』と申光璞『蔚陵島事蹟』

1696年 - 幕府の「渡航禁制令」

1711年 - 朴昌錫「鬱陵島圖形」

1711年 - 鬱稜島に派遣された検察官朴昌錫の残した碑文

1736 ~ 1767年 - 「輿地圖」 - 鬱陵于山両島

1737~1776年 - 廣輿圖 - 江原道と鬱陵島

1700年中期 - 「八道輿地圖」 - 鬱陵島

1793年 - 韓国の記録「日省録」に記された"松島"

1800年代以前(推定) - 東京山川 八道地圖

1807年5月12日 - 李泰根が鬱陵島を検察する

1836年 - 会津屋八右衛門による竹嶋一件と「竹嶋渡海一件記 全」 (竹島事件 会津屋八右衛門)

1840~1860年頃 - 隠岐国松島 (文鳳堂a.k.a 山城屋忠兵衛「文鳳堂雑纂」)

1853-1922年 - 肝付兼行 (Kimotsuki Kaneyuki)

1861年 - 金正浩「大東輿地圖」

1864年 - 日本の地図に現れる竹島と松島は瓜ふたつ

1876年 - 島根県の報告「渡海禁制のいきさつ」

1876年 - 島根県の報告「(竹島の)由来の概略」

1877年 - "松島"に関する様々な意見:「松島巡視要否ノ議」 外務省公信局長 田邊太一

1878年 - 「松島の儀」外務省記録局長 渡邊洪基

1882年 - 4月7日 高宗が于山島は鬱陵島の隣接島であると述べたこと

1894年 - 海軍省水路部「朝鮮水路誌」(明治二十七年)

1899年9月23日 - 皇城新聞記事「鬱陵島 事況」

1899 - 9月 27日 - 古川鈊三郎「軍艦摩耶 報告書」

1899 - 10月 3日 - 高雄謙三「鬱陵島出張復命書」

1899 - 10月10日 - 摩耶艦長海軍中佐松本有信「軍艦摩耶 報告書」

1901年 - 大韓帝国地理書「大韓地誌」玄采著附属江原道地図

1902年 - 外務省通商局編纂「通商彙纂」

1902年4月 - 大韓帝国内部 『鬱島郡節目』

1903年 - 韓海通漁指針

1904年 - リャンコ島領土編入並二貸下願 (中井養三郎)

1904年2月20日 - 「満韓新図」

1904年9月25日 - 韓国名"独島"が竹島/Liancourt Rocksを示すのに使われた始めての記録

1905年1月28日 - 閣議決定資料

1905年 - 軍艦橋立の竹島調査

1905年 - 外務省通商局編纂「通商彙纂」 第50号

1905 - 5月 29 , 30日 & 6月5日- 官報号外「日本海海戦戦報」

1906年 - 02月 26日 ~ 4月17日 - 「內部來去案 第一冊」 大韓帝国、統監府に抗議し日本人による韓国の領土収奪を阻止する

1907年 - (明治四十年)「朝鮮水路誌」

1946(昭和21)年2月 - 外務省外交文書「旧日本外地情況雑件  2.行政の分離に関する司令部側との会談 」

1948 - Jan. - 宋錫夏"OOLNUNGDO, HISTORIC ISLAND OF KOREA"(古色蒼然な 歴史的遺跡 鬱陵島を捜して)

1948 - 12月12日 - 申奭鎬「独島所属について」『史海』創刊第一号

1950年代の竹島をめぐる論争における日韓それぞれの主張

1950年 - オーストラリア政府の質問に対する米国の回答

1953 - 昭和28年の竹島に関する国会審議

1954年 - ヴァン・フリート使節団報告書

1960 - 申奭鎬「獨島の来歴」(雑誌『思想界』), Part 1

1960 - 申奭鎬「獨島の来歴」(雑誌『思想界』), Part 2

1966 - 2月 - 兪鎮午「韓日会談が開かれるまで」(上)『思想界』1966年2月号

1974年 - 5月22日~24日 - 東亜日報「秘話 第一共和国 276-278 : 第十一話 李承晩と日本 4-6」

竹島問題の歴史

鬱陵島検察使のこの地図は、子山嶋をあらわしているか?

安龍福の言う倭の松島=子山島(于山島)はやはり竹嶼だった

イガ島、まの島、マノ島に共通するものは?

18世紀の隠岐ノ松島 「竹島図説」

明治期の欝陵島~竹島/独島関連の日本製地図

1894-1948 朝鮮領土の境界

Web竹島問題研究所の記事を翻訳する許可を得ました

竹島の歴史入門(日本語版)・History of Dokdo for beginners (Korean version)

中央日報「独島を守ろう」と作った教科書に誤り15カ所

「竹島問題に関する国際法論文選」出版プロジェクト2009

Q & As (English ; 英語)

Q1: Has Dokdo been a part of Korea since the sixth century?

Q 2: What is Ulleungdo's largest neighboring island?

Q 3: Why did old Korean maps show Ulleungdo as two islands?

Q 4: Did King Sejong's geography text mention Dokdo?

Q 5: Did Korea's 1530 "Sinjeung Dongguk Yeoji Seungram" mention Dokdo?

Recommended Articles (English)

1412 - Koreans on Ulleungdo's neighboring island of Jukdo

1454 - Another Picture of “Dokdo” from Ulleungdo? (1454年 世宗実録「地理志」)

Where have all the Usandos gone?

Korean Scholar Says "Usando" Was Ulleungdo's "Jukdo"

Ulleungdo's Neighboring Island of Jukdo (죽도 - 竹島)

KBS Documentary on "Jukdo," the Real Usando

What do イガ島, まの島 and マノ島, have in common?

1470 - "Sambongdo(三峯島)" was just an another name of Ulleundo, not Takeshima/Dokdo

1656 - "Yojiji (輿地志)" by Ryu Hyung-won (柳馨遠) didn't say "Usan is so-called Japanese Matsushima."

Mid 17th century - Illustrative Map of Matsushima (松嶋絵図) by Murakawa Clan

1667 - Onshu Shicho Goki (隠州視聴合記)

1694 - Jang Han-sang (張漢相) Finds Sambongdo (三峯島)

1696 - Ahn's so-called Matsushima/Usando was Jukdo, afterall. (元禄九丙子年朝鮮舟着岸一巻之覚書 肅宗実録 30卷, 22年 戊寅)

1696c.a. - "Illustrative Map of Takeshima submitted by Kotani Ihei(小谷伊兵衛より差出候竹嶋之絵図)"

1711 - Bak Chang-seok's (朴昌錫) Map of Ulleungdo (鬱陵島圖形)

1794 - June 3 - "正祖実録 正祖18年6月3日条" Gajido(可支島) was described as a place on or near Ulleungdo, not Takeshima/Dokdo.

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 8 : "An Yong-bok, Usando, & Matsushima (Songdo)" 肅宗実録(1696), 鬱陵島圖形(1711), 鬱陵島事蹟(1694), 海東地圖(1750s), 輿地圖(1736-67), 朝鮮地圖(1750-1768), 地乘(1776-1800), 東國文獻備考(1770), 日省録(1793), 萬機要覽(1808), 靑邱圖(1835), 朝鮮国交際始末内探書(1869), 高宗実録(1882), 鬱陵島外圖(1882), 大韓全図(1899), 皇城新聞(1899), 大韓勅令勅令第41号(1900)

1807 May 12 - Lee Tae-gun (李泰根) Inspects Ulleungdo (日省録 : 北有于山島周回爲二三里許南至都庄仇味)

1835 - "Map of Asia and Small Orient(亜細亜小東洋圖)" shows Takeshima/Dokdo as Japanese territory (長久保赤水 唐土歴代州郡沿革地図 亜細亜小東洋圖)

1882 April 7 - King Kojong says Usando Neighboring Island of Ulleungdo (高宗 19卷, 19年 4月 7日 壬戌)

1900 - Imperial Edict Makes Ulleungdo a County of Gangwon Province (大韓勅令第41号)

1906 - Feb 20 & April 17 - "Official Documents of the Ministry of Internal Affairs Vol.1" - Korean government protested about land transaction in 竹邊浦
Korean Imperial government officially acquiesced the Japan's sovereignty over Takeshima/Dokdo
by not expressing protest against Japan.

Investigation of Japanese maps during Meiji period before the incorporation of Liancourt rocks

Korean Eastern limits described in various books world wide exclude Takeshima/Dokdo from Korean Territory

The Territorial Recognitions which Western Maps of Japan Show for Takeshima/Liancour Rocks between 1880-1905 : Ver.1

1951 - August - Rusk's Letter - #12 ( As regards the island of Dokdo, otherwise known as Takeshima or Liancourt Rocks, this normally uninhabited rock formation was according to our information never treated as part of Korea and, since about 1905, has been under the jurisdiction of the Oki Islands Branch Office of Shimane Prefecture of Japan. The island does not appear ever before to have been claimed by Korea. )

1953 - Jul 22 - US Doc. Reconfirms Dean Rusk Letter (Memorandum by Mr. Robert A. Fearey of the Office of Northeast Asian Affairs)

1954 - Report of Van Fleet mission to the Far East


英語での本ブログ投稿記事(年代順)(Blog Articles in Historical Date Order)

1412 - Koreans on Ulleungdo's neighboring island of Jukdo" (世宗實錄 卷 "牛山茂陵兩島")

1436 Jun 19 - Gangwondo Governor Asks to Populate "Muleungdo's Usan" (世宗實錄 卷 七十三, 世宗 十八年 閏六月 甲申條 "武陵島牛山")

1457 - Apr 16 - "The two islands of Usando and Muleungdo are suitable for settlements."

1470 - "Sambongdo(三峯島)" was just an another name of Ulleundo, not Takeshima/Dokdo

1530 - "Paldo Chongdo" (八道總圖) - "Map of the Eight Provinces"

1530 - "Takeshima in the Korean official map" by Funasugi Rikinobu (舩杉力修) - (1) 「八道総図」 in 『新増東国輿地勝覧』

1600's? - The Map of Joseon(朝鮮国図)

17th C. Korean Map - "Paldo Jeondo" (八道全図)  (”自此以東方日本”)

1600s - Map of Silla, Goguryo, & Baekje Regions (支那朝鮮古地圖 - 지나조선고지도)

1600s - "Map of the Original Regions of Silla, Goguryeo, & Baeje" (新羅高勾麗百濟肇造區域之圖) from "Dongyeo Bigo" (東輿備攷) Maps

Three Kingdoms Map from 1600's

1618 - Permission Given to the Oya and Murakawa Families (幕府 鳥取藩主 村川家 大屋家 竹島(欝陵島)渡航許可書)

Mid 17th century - Illustrative Map of Matsushima (松嶋絵図) by Murakawa Clan

1656 - "Yojiji (輿地志)" by Ryu Hyung-won (柳馨遠) didn't say "Usan is so-called Japanese Matsushima."

Mid 1600s-1682 - "Gi-eon(記 言)" by Kim Si-seop(金時習) : "From Weolsong he viewed Ulleung/Usan." (越松望鬱陵于山)

Later 1700s - "Aguk Chongdo" (我國摠圖)

1662 - "Cheokjuji (陟州誌)" by Heo Mok (許穆 - 허목) - Ulleungdo (鬱陵島) : 或云于山鬱陵一島方百里在海中蔚珎之東

1667 - Onshu Shicho Goki (隠州視聴合記)

1667 - "Onshu Shicho Goki(隠州視聴合記)" - The different translations

1692-1693 - The 1692 and 1693 incidents: Ahn Yong-bok's(安龍福) first visit to Japan

1693-1696 - The Takeshima incident(竹島一件): the 1st dispute between Japan and Korea

1694 - Jang Han-sang (張漢相) Finds Sambongdo (三峯島)

1694 - "Ulleungdo Sajeok" (蔚陵島事蹟) - A 1694 Ulleungdo Inspection Report

1696 - Ahn Yong-bok's(安龍福) second visit to Japan: Part I (竹島一件)

1696 - Ahn Yong-bok's (安龍福) second visit to Japan: Part II (竹島一件)

1696c.a. - "Illustrative Map of Takeshima submitted by Kotani Ihei(小谷伊兵衛より差出候竹嶋之絵図)"

1696 - Ordinance Prohibiting Voyages to Takeshima (幕府 渡航禁制令)

1696 - Ahn's so-called Matsushima/Usando was Jukdo, afterall.

1699? - Today's Kwannundo(観音島) and Small Udo(小于島) in 「欝陵島図形」 by Choson Official Inspector, the Identical Figures.

1700s? - Korean Atlas "Yojido" (朝鮮摠図)

1711 - Bak Chang-seok's (朴昌錫) Map of Ulleungdo (鬱陵島圖形)

1711 - "Takeshima in the Korean official map" by Funasugi Rikinobu (舩杉力修) - (2)「欝陵島図形」

1711 - Ulleungdo Inspector Bak Chang-seok's (朴昌錫) 1711 Inscription

1714 - July 22 - "Visible to the east of Ulleung is an island that is on the border of Japan." (補闕正吳)

1724 - Oki's Matsushima in the 18th century (竹島図説 "隠岐の松島")

1736 ~ 1767 - Yeojido (輿地圖) - Ulleung/Usan (鬱陵于山兩島)

1737 ~ 1776 - "Gwang Yeodo" (廣輿圖) - Gangwondo & Ulleungdo

Mid 1700s - "Paldo Yeojido" (八道輿地圖) - Ulleungdo Map (鬱陵島圖)

1742 - 朝鮮八道総図(萩藩当職山内広通と浜崎代官清水親全の命により描いた彩色図)  - (「蔚珍之内風日清明即峯頭樹木及山根沙渚歴々可見風便二日可渡海有林落基址七即今空虚」)

1744 - Chungwanji (春官志) - "Ulleungdo is called Sambongdo (三峰島)" (李孟休 春官志 鬱陵島 爭界)

Early 1750s - "Haedong Jido" (海東地圖) - Ulleungdo

1750~1768 - Joseon Jido (朝鮮地圖) - Ulleungdo

1752 - Fang-ling-tau means Ulleungdo

1754 - "The Field Chart of Japan, The Atlas of Japan (日本輿地図 日本分野図)" by Mori Kohan( 森幸安) described Takeshima(Ulleungdo) as Japan's territory

1760s - Korean Atlas "Seonyeokdo" (鮮域圖)

1770 - "Takeshima in the Korean official map" by Funasugi Rikinobu (舩杉力修) - (3) 「欝陵島図 in'『朝鮮地図』

1777-1787 - Haedong Yeojido (海東輿地圖) - Ulleungdo

1786 - June 4 - Kim Chang-yun (金昌胤) Inspects Ulleungdo (日省録)

1790 - "A Map of China and Surroundings(華夷一覧図) "by Kimura Kenkado(木村蒹葭堂)

1793 - Korean Record: "Songdo another name for Ulleungdo" (日省録)

1794 - June 3 - Han Chang-guk (韓昌國) Inspects Ulleungdo (日省録)

1794 - June 3 - "正祖実録 正祖18年6月3日条" Gajido(可支島) was described as a place on or near Ulleungdo, not Takeshima/Dokdo.

1795-1800 - Dong Yeodo (東輿圖) - Ulleungdo (鬱陵島)

1796 - "日本並北方図" - 本多利明 - 幕命

1798 - The old chart of Dagelet

Before 1800s? - Donggyeong San Cheon (東京山川) - Paldo Jido (八道地圖)

Late Lee Dynasty - Ulleungdo and Usan were visible from Korean peninsula (江原道古地図(Kanwondo old map))

Late 18th c., "Joseon Paldo Jido," Ulleungdo & Usando (朝鮮八道地圖)

18th/19th? Century Map of Ulleungdo & Usando (朝鮮八道圖)

19th c. Map of Ulleungdo: "Ulleungdo Dohyeong" (鬱陵島圖形), property of Samcheok Museum

1800 - 1822 - Joseon-do - Ulleungdo (朝鮮圖 - 鬱陵島)

1807 - May 12 - Lee Tae-gun (李泰根) Inspects Ulleungdo (日省録)

1807 - San-in Chuo Shimpo: "Usando (于山島) = Jukdo (竹嶼), Documented for the First Time"

1816 - 大日本接壌三国之全図 - 大阪 其由堂・旭栄堂合梓

1817 - Aaron Arrowsmith's map of Japan and Von Siebold

1822 - Jido - Gwandongdo (地圖 - 關東圖)

1823 - "Haedong Yeoksa sok" (海東繹史續) - "萬歷二十五年倭分屯松島蔚山釜山鎭書 謹案文獻備考于山島卽倭所謂松島也 輿地勝覽 于山鬱陵本一島..."

1827 - May 19 - Ha Si-myeong (河始明) Inspects Ulleungdo (日省録)

1831 - May 14 - Lee Gyeong-jeong (李慶鼎) Inspects Ulleungdo (日省録)

1834 - Korean Map: "Cheonggudo" (靑邱圖) 金正浩

1834 - Cheonggudo (靑邱圖) 1834 Map by Kim Jong-ho 金正浩

1835 - "Map of Asia and Small Orient(亜細亜小東洋圖)" shows Takeshima/Dokdo as Japanese territory (長久保赤水 唐土歴代州郡沿革地図 亜細亜小東洋圖)

1835 - Late 18th & 19th Century Japanese Maps Showed Ulleungdo & Liancourt Rocks as Japanese ( 長久保赤水 唐土歴代州郡沿革地図 亜細亜小東洋圖)

1836 - Japanese Man Executed for Sailing to Ulleungdo (会(今)津屋八右衛門 竹島事件)

1837 - Japanese sign to be auctioned off (八右衛門 竹島事件 高札)

1840-1860 c. Matsushima of Oki County (文鳳堂a.k.a 山城屋忠兵衛「文鳳堂雑纂」)

1840 - Aaron Arrowsmith's map of Japan and Von Siebold ("Atlas von Land- und Seekarten vom Japanischen Reiche Dai-Nippon" in 1851.)

1842 - Okajima Masayoshi Wrote of Ahn Yong-bok's Flag and Claims (岡島正義 因府歴年大雑集)

1846 - French map of Korea (Coree)

1849 - 2007 - "Takeshima in Japanese map (1)" by Funasugi Rikinobu 1(「嘉永新増 大日本国郡輿地全図」)

Latter 1800s: "Dae Dongyeo Jido" (大東輿地圖)(東輿) - Ulleungdo (鬱陵島) ( with "Usando" (于山島) 

1853-1922 - Kimotsuki Kaneyuki (肝付兼行)

1853 - 萬国地球全図、大日本輿地図略 東都 鈴亭谷義蔵版 - 嘉永6年

1855 - Mid-19th c. Map of Samcheok District & Ulleungdo (地圖 江原道 咸鏡道)

1855 - French map of Korea (Coree)

1855 - Colton's "Japan"

1855 - What does this 1855 Jpn map of Oki say? (第四十八 隠岐島)

1855 - Imperial Gazetteer Volume One, UK

1855 - Pronouncing Gazetteer, USA

1858 - British Publication "China Pilot," 2nd Edition (1858)

1860 - 1870? - Japanese map of Korea (朝鮮國全図) (瀬脇壽人)

1861 - Daedong Yeojido (大東輿地圖) - Ulleungdo Map

1861 - "Dae Dongyeo Jido" (大東輿地圖) with Unique "Index Map"

1861 - "Daedong Yeojido (大東輿地圖)" at Univ. of Wisconsin - Milwaukee

1861 - British Publication "China Pilot," 3rd Edition (1861)

1861 - Late 18th & 19th Century Japanese Maps Showed Ulleungdo & Liancourt Rocks as Japanese (新刊輿地全図)

1863 - Description of Ulleungdo from Kim Jeong-ho's "Daedongjiji" (金正浩 大東地志 )

1863 Korean Map from Japanese Woodblock Encyclopedia (江戸大節用海内蔵)

1864 - Japanese Map shows 2 similar islands (増訂大日本輿地全図)

1864 - British Publication "China Pilot," 4th Edition, 1864

1865 c - French map of Korea ( Corée)

1870 - "How Takeshima & Matsushima Became Part of Joseon" (朝鮮国交際始末内探書「竹島松島朝鮮附属ニ相成候始末」 )

1873 - British Publication "China Sea Directory," 1st Edition, Vol. 4 (1873)

1873 - Japanese Map Shows Takeshima & Matsushima as Japanese (Carte de l'empire du Japon publiee par la Commision Imperiale Exposition Universelle de VIENNE 1873 by Japanese Meiji Government)*

1874 - "Histoire de L'Eglise de Corée" by Claude Charles Dallet

1875 - "Chosen Yochi Zenzu" by Sekiguchi Bisyo (關口備正) (朝鮮輿地全図)

1876 - General Gazetteer, UK

1876 - "Keirinjiryaku(鶏林事略)" by Sewaki Hisato (瀬脇寿人)excludes Takeshima/Dokdo from Choson

1876 - "Argument for the Development of Matsushima" (武藤平学 松島開拓之議)

1876 - Shimane prefecture explains the history of Takeshima in 1876 (Part 1/2) (島根県 渡航禁止のいきさつ)

1876 - Shimane prefecture explains the history of Takeshima in 1876 (Part 2/2) (島根県 (竹島の)由来の概略)

1877 - Argument about "another island": details of the compiled official documents (公文禄) of the Ministry of the Interior (太政官指令)

1877 - Jpn Map of Ulleungdo (磯竹島略図)

1877 - Jpn Map Shows "Matsushima" (松島) as Japanese (文部省出版 宮本三平「日本全図」)*

1877/78 - Watanabe Says Liancourt Rocks are Japanese (竹島考証 : 渡辺洪基 「松島之儀一」)

1877/78 - Different Japanese Views on Matsushima (竹島考証 : 田辺太一 「松島巡視要否ノ議」(意見 : 甲乙丙))

1877/8 - Unfinished Translation of an 1878? Document (竹島考証 : 渡辺洪基 「中間意見」)

1880s - 1890s - Gwandong Pangyeo - Ulleungdo (關東方輿 -鬱陵島)

1880 - R. Hausermann's Map of Korea ( Corée)

1880 - German Map of Japan from Adolf Stieler's Hand Atlas 7th Edition (National Border between Ulleungdo and Choson)*

1880 - Japanese Warship "Amagi" (軍艦天城) Surveys Ulleungdo and finds "Takeshima" is Jukdo.

1881 - Kitazawa Masanari(北澤正誠), a official of MOFA concluded that "Takeshima" is Jukdo in "A Study of Takeshima (Takeshima Kosho 竹島考証) "

1881 - Oki & Matsushima Same Color on 1881 Japanese Map ( Geographic Bureau of the Ministry of Interior (内務省地理局) 大日本府県分轄図 大日本全国略図)*

1882 April 7 - King Kojong says Usando Neighboring Island of Ulleungdo (高宗実録 19卷, 19年 4月 7日 壬戌)

1882 - "Takeshima in the Korean official map" by Funasugi Rikinobu (舩杉力修) - (4) 『鬱陵島外図』

1882 - "The Joseon Situation" (朝鮮事情), by Enomoto Takeaki(榎本武揚) excludes Takeshima/Dokdo from Joseon territory

1882 - Shinsen Chosen Yochi Zenzu (新撰朝鮮輿地全圖) by Wakabayashi Tokusaburo (若林篤三郞)

1882 Aug 5 - Japanese newspaper 自由新聞

1883 - Japanese "Seaways Magazine" (日本水路誌)

1883 - Mar. 1 - The island that Japan calls Matushima or Takeshima and Korea calls Ulleungdo (The Draft of Official Notice : 内達案)

1883 - Japanese Map of Ulleungdo (朝鮮国蔚陵島出張桧垣内務省書記官復命ノ件)

1884 - British Publication "China Sea Directory," 2nd Edition, Vol. 4 (1884)

1893 - Lanier "L'Asie" excluded Takeshima/Liancourt Rocks (Dokdo) from Korean territory

1884 - Appleton Map of Japan and Korea, USA

1884~1894 - Map of Ulleungdo (鬱陵島) & Usando (于山島) (it shows an island off the east shore of Ulleungdo (鬱陵島) labeled as "Udo" (于島))

1886 - Dec. - 寰瀛水路誌 第二巻第二版 韓露沿岸 (Japanese Seaway Directory, Choson and Russia )*

1888 - British map of Japan and Corea (no Liancourt Rocks, but the borderline indicated that Dagelet island was Japan's territory)*

1891 - German Map "Ost-China, Korea und Japan"  ( Stieler, Adolf; Gotha; Justus Perthes)*

1891 - American map of Japan (People’s Publishing Co. in Chicago)  

1891 - American map of Japan (International Cyclopaedia)Taka, Matsu and Liancourt Rocks

1892 - A description of Ulleungdo (”鄭處士述懷歌”)

1892 -  Podzhio "Overview Korea" - Russian Diplomat dropped Takeshima/Dokdo from Gangwon-do.

1892 - German Map of ”China und Japan” ("Meyers Kleiner Handatlas," Leipzig)*

1893 - Andree's Allgemeiner Handatlas **
It shows Ulleungdo = Korean , Liancourt Rocks = Japanese

1893 - "The Sea Chart of Hokkaido and Northeastern Islands(北洲及北東諸島)" plots Waywoda Rock far outside of Korean territory

1893 - "Yeoljae Chwalyo" (輿載撮要 - 여재촬요) - Map of Samcheok (三陟) and Ulleungdo (鬱陵島) 

1893 - German Map ”Ubersichtskarte von China und Japan”

1894 - French map of Korea and Japan (Is. Liancourt ou Hornet (Jap))

1894 - Carte De La Coree from "Le Petit Journal"

1894 - British map of Japan (Edward Stanford, Charing Cross, London) * Three islands

1894 - American map of Japan (Cram Universal)

1894 - "Jissoku Chosen Zenzu" (實側朝鮮全圖) by So Mokan (宗孟寬)

1894 - Japanese map of Korea, "Chosen Yochizu" (朝鮮輿地図)

1894 - Japanese map "日清韓三国地図"

1894 - British Publication "China Sea Directory," 3rd Edition, Vol 4 (1894)

1894 - British map of Japan and Korea (Popular Atlas of The World)* Three islands, with National border between Argonaut & Dagelet

1894 (1897) German map of Japan and Korea ("JAPAN UND KOREA", Leipzig, Germany)*

1894 Jan 14 - New Japanese Boat Visits Ulleungdo (山陰新報 "漁船改良丸の好果")

1894 - February 18 - Article on an Ulleungdo Inspection (山陰新報 "朝鮮竹島探檢 (松江佐_狂水生投)")

1894 - Jpn Gazetteer: Usando "in the vicinity of Ulleungdo" (于山島:蔚陵島ノ近傍) (三橋僊史著『朝鮮地名案内』)

1894-1897 - From "Korea and Her Neighbors" by Isabella Lucy Bird.

1894-1895 - British Map of Corea and Map of Islands of Japan (W. & A. K. Johnston, Edinburgh & London)

1895 - 紇法『士民必知』 (Knowledge Necessary for All) excluded Takeshima from the Country of Korea.

1895 - Map of Japan: The TIMES Atlas) * three islands

1896 - "Japan and Korea" by J.G. Bartholomew (UK)* no colour but national border between Choson and Matsushima(Dagelet)

1896 - "Central Japan" by J.G. Bartholomew (UK)* Includes Liancourt Rocks

1897 - German map of ”Japan Und Korea”) (Leipzig, Germany)

1897 - German map "CHINA, KOREA UND JAPAN"* no colour but national border between Choson and Matsushima(Dagelet)

1897 - American map of Japan and Korea (The Century Atlas)*Three islands

1897 - Bacon's Popular Atlas of the World: Map of Japan and Korea

1898 - Korean Map of Gangwondo & Ulleungdo (地圖 江原道 咸鏡道)

1898 - British Map "Japan Islands" (London, James Imray and Son )

1899 - Korean Map: "Daehanjeondo" (大韓全圖) (玄采 大韓地誌)

1899 - "Takeshima in the Korean official map" by Funasugi Rikinobu (舩杉力修) - (5) 『大韓全図』(1899) , 『大韓輿地図』(1900 c.a.)

1899 - Did the 1899 "Joseon Seaways Directory" Mention "Dokdo"? (朝鮮水路誌)

1898 - American Map "Empires of China, Japan and Korea" (Chicago: J. Martin Miller)

1899 - American map of Japan and 1894 Japanese map of Korea (Map of Japan : George F. Cram of Chicago)

1899 - American Map of Japan (George F. Cram of Chicago) *Three islands

1899 - Sep 23 - "Hwangseong Sinmun" (皇城新聞) 1899 Sep 23: Ulleungdo Situation

1899 - Sep 27 - Report of Ulleungdo by Japanese warship Maya

1900 - The Times Map (China and Japan, Printing House, London)**It shows Ulleungdo = Korean , Liancourt Rocks = Japanese

1900 - The Times Map : map of China (East) and Korea

1900 - Russian Ministry of Finance  "Overview of Korea" - Korean easternmost is Ulleungdo(130°54′ E.) , not Liancourt Rocks

1900 - Japanese map of Ulleungdo (赤塚正助 鬱陵島山林概況)

1900 - "Uldo-gi" (鬱島記), by U Yong-jeong (禹用鼎)

1900 - Oct. 22 - A petition by 李乾夏 "鬱陵島를鬱島로改稱하고島監을郡守로改正에關한請議書", which excluded Dokdo from Uldo County.

1900 - Imperial Edict Makes Ulleungdo a County of Gangwon Province (大韓勅令第41号)

1901 - "Daehanjiji" (大韓地誌) Map of Korea's Gangwon Province (玄采)

1901 - No Korean Fishermen on Ulleungdo in 1901 (Kim Ho-dong (김호동) The History of Dokdo & Ulleungdo (독도, 울릉도의 역사) )

1902 - Japanese Document Describing Ulleungdo (外務省通商局編纂 通商彙纂)

1902 - German map of "Japan und Korea" *

1903 - The Fishery Guide of Sea around Korea (黒龍会 韓海通漁指針)

1903 - Mar 30 - "Hwangseong Sinmun": "于山島에 二百二十名" (皇城新聞)

1903 - German Map of Japan which was owned by German Embassy *

1903 - Encyclopaedia Britannica Map

1904 - German map of Japan

1904 - February 20th Japanese map of Korea and Manchuria (満韓新図 日露戦争実記)*

1904 - Canadian Business Map of Japan ( Rand McNally Business Atlas)*

1904 - American Map "The Seat of the Japan-Russian War" (Geo.F.Cram, Chicago) *

1904 - British Map of "Eastern China, Japan and Korea" (Edward Stanford, London) Three islands

1904 - British Publication "Sailing Directions" (1904)

1904 - American Map of Japan, Korea & Manchuria (C.S. Hammond & Co., New York) Three islands

1904 - "Hammond map of Japan, Korea and Manchuria"Hammond's Atlas of the World (C.S. Hammond & Co., New York) * Three islands

1904 - September 29 - Petition to Incorporate Ryanko-to (Liancourt Rocks) (中井養三郎 リャンコ島領土編入並二貸下願 )

1904 - Sep 25 - First Record of "Dokdo" for Liancourt Rocks (軍艦新高行動日誌)

1904 - History of Joseon Civilization (恒屋盛服 朝鮮開化史 - 조선개화사)

1904-1905 - Ulleungdo drawn by Japanese fleet #19

1904-1905 - Watchtowers during the Russo-Japanese War

1905 - "Trade Documents" by MOFA (外務省通商局編纂 通商彙纂)

1905 - January 5th - The Report about Laincourt Rocks by the captain of the naval ship Tsushima, Commander Sendo Takeo (對馬艦長海軍中佐仙頭武央"竹島報告")

1905 - January 28th: the decision to incorporate Takeshima in to Shimane by a Cabinet meeting (公文類集第29編 竹島編入閣議決定)

1905 - Feb 24 - Takeshima Incorporated into Shimane Prefecture (山陰新報 "隠岐の新島")

1905 - Mar. 15 - (隱岐新報): Japan "officially" incorporates "Takashima"

1905 - May 29 , 30 & June 5- An Extra of Official Gazette "The War Report of The Japan Naval Battle"(官報号外)

1905 - June 2 - 皇城新聞 : Korean called "Liancourt Rocks(リアンコルド岩)" as "Angohu島", not "Dokdo", Seokdo nor Usando.

1905 - June 3 - Japanese Magazine "The Chronicle of Japan-Russo War (日露戦争実記)"

1905 - June 5 - Tokyo Asahi Shimbun Corrected "Liancourt Rocks" as "Takeshima"

1905 - June 12 - A Report of Liancourt Rocks by a naval engineer Kiguchi Kichigoro (戦艦橋立海軍技手木口吉五郎"竹島視察報告")

1905 - June 14 - A Report of "Takeshima" (Liancourt Rocks) by Rear Admiral Taketomi Kunikane (第三艦隊司令官海軍少将武富邦鼎"竹島視察報告")

1905 - June 15 - Japanese Cruiser Hashidate Surveys Takeshima (Liancourt Rocks) (橋立戦時日誌)

1905 - June 15 - A Report of TakeshimaWarship Hashidate Captain Fukui Masayoshi (printed version) (戦艦橋立艦長海軍大佐福井正義"竹島視察報告")

1905 - Jul 3 - "Postcards to Commemorate Naval Battle" (山陰新報 " 海戦記念絵葉書")

1905 - Aug 6 - Japanese Officials to Visit Takeshima (山陰新報 "竹島渡航")

1905 - Aug 11 - "日本民族の新發展 滿韓露領地誌"

1905 - Aug 22 - "Governor Matsunaga Inspects Takeshima" (山陰新報 "松永知事の竹島視察")

1905 - Aug 22 - "Sea Pigs" Near Takeshima (山陰新報 "県庁内に海豚放養")

1906 - Feb 20 & April 17 - "Official Documents of the Ministry of Internal Affairs Vol.1" - Korean government protested about land transaction in 竹邊浦

1906 - Mar 11 - "Voyage to Takeshima Decided" (山陰新報 "竹島行決定")

1906 - July - the Korean Self-Strengthening Society (大韓自强會) blotted out Takeshima/Dokdo from its monthly magazine in 1906.

1906 - Jul 13 - Korea Omits Dokdo from Uldo County (皇城新聞 「鬱島郡의 配置顛末」)

1906 - Jul 13 - Daehan Maeil Shinbo "Ikeda's Official Letter(池田公文書簡
)" - Japanese Resident-General made inquiry about Uldo County, not Ulleung Island.

1906 - Apr 1 - Japanese Tell Koreans of Takeshima Incorporation (山陰新報 "竹島土産")

1906 - Apr 8 - "Diary of My Trip to Takeshima" # 3 (山陰新報 "竹嶋渡海日記")

1906 - Sep 26 - Boundary Survey of Uldo County Conducted (皇城新聞 "鬱島戸口")

1906 - "Daehan Jiji" (大韓地誌) by Hyeon Chae (玄采)

1907 - "Chodeung Daehan Jiji" (初等大韓地誌)

1907 June - "Sinpyeon Daehan Jiri" (新編 大韓地理)

1907 - Daehan Shinjiji Attached Maps (大韓新地志附地圖)

1907 - Japan's "Joseon Seaways Directory" (朝鮮水路誌)

1909 - Japan's "Korean Fisheries Guide" ( 韓国水産誌 鬱陵島全図 )

1913 - Jun 22- Location of Usando Unknown in Early 1900s (毎日申報 "無人島探検中止")

1917 - Map of Korea (朝鮮地図 朝鮮総督府)

1917 & 1918 - Maps of Ulleungdo (鬱陵島図 朝鮮総督府)

1918 - Japanese Map of Ulleungdo (鬱陵島図 朝鮮総督府)

1918 - "Latest Joseon Geography" (藤戸計太 最新朝鮮地理 - 최신 조선지리)

1919 - National Geographic Map of Korea

1922 - "Map of Daehanminguk" (대한민국 디도) (大韓民国図)

1923 - Shimane Prefecture Journal (島根県誌)

1928 - The name of Kwannondo(観音島) came from the "Stone Buddhas (石仏)" on the island. (東亜日報)

1934 Jan 30 - "Maeil Sinbo" - Article on Ulleungdo "鬱陵島란 엇더한 곳인가"

1939 - Jpn textbook shows Liancourt Rocks as Korean? (尋常小学国史絵図)

1941 - ”Geography Text of Kangwon Province (江原道誌)” reconfirms it is Ulleungdo which can be seen and it is from Ulgin

1944 - 1984 - National Geographic Maps

after 1945 - "Geography for Middle School(中等地理)" by the Association of Gyeongbuk Geographers(慶北地理學會) admits Dokdo is outside of the territory of Korea

1945-1953 - Map of Korea (USA) (Geographia map Co., INC in New York) excludes Liancourt Rocks from Korea

1945-1953 - Map of Japan (USA) (Geographia map Co., INC in New York) includes Liancourt Rocks in Japan

1946 - Jan. 29 - SCAPIN 677

1946 - Feb. 13 - "Conference with GHQ/SCAP concerning separation of the administration"

1946 - Jun. 22 - SCAPIN 1033

1947 - Sep. 16 -SCAPIN 1778

1947 - Roh Do-yang "National Geographic Student Atlas for Middle School” excluded Takeshima/Dokdo from Korea

1947 - Sep. 2 - Sok Ju-myong(石宙明)'s "History of Ulleungdo " says that Jukdo has been the eastern edge point of Joseon.

1949 - Nov. 14 - Willam J. Sebald's telegram

1949 - Nov. 19 - A letter from W. Walton Butterworth

1949 - Dec. 29 - U.S. Draft made on December 29, 1949

1950 - July - Commentary on Draft Treaty by the Department of State

1950's - Korean Video: "Dokdo & the Peace Line"

1950's - Japan & Korea Argue Their Claims in 1950s Letters

1949 - U.S. Maps DOES NOT Confirm Korean Sovereignty Over Dokdo

1950 -中央人民政府人民革命軍事委員会作戦部測絵局 『朝鲜地图』 - People's Republic of China excluded Takeshima/Dokdo from " Map of Korea"

1950 - Oct 26 - USA answers to Australian government (Memorandum by Mr. Robert A. Fearey of the Office of Northeast Asian Affairs)

1950 - The Daily Telegraph Map of Korea

1940s-1950s - Geographia Map Company's Large Scale Map of Korea (USA)

1950's - Rand McNally Official War Map of Korea

1951 - Apr. - May: Joint UK and USA Draft - extra(1)

1951 - Jun. 1 - New Zealand's view - extra(2)

1951 - Jul. 6 - SCAPIN 2160 (cache)

1951 - Jul 9 - Coversation of Yu Chan Yang with John F. Dulles

1951 - Jul 19 - The 2nd Conversation between Yu Chan Yang and John F. Dulles

1951 - Aug 2 - Another letter from You Chan Yang

1951 - Aug 3 - Bogg’s Memorandum

1951 - August 9 -Dean Rusk Letter (A letter by US Secretary of State Dean Rusk to the Korean Ambassador )

1951 - Sep 9 - San Francisco Peace Treaty

1951 - Sep 21 - Korean Government comprehended Takeshima/Dokdo was affirmed as a Japanese Territory in Peace Treaty

1952- Jan 18 - Syngman Rhee Line

1952 - Nov. 5 - Confidential Security Information of USA

1952 - Dec. 4 - Confidential Security Information of USA

1952 - Dec 4 - “American Embassy’s Note Verbale No.187” - U.S. iterates Rusk Note to ROK.

1953 Jul 22 - Confidential Security Information of USA “Possible Methods of Resolving Liancourt Rocks Dispute between Japan and ROK”( The United States Government's understanding of the territorial status of this island was stated in assistant Secretary dated August 10,1951.")

1953 - Jul 22 - US Doc. Reconfirms Dean Rusk Letter (Letter from Office of Northeast Asian Affairs To E. Allan Lightner American Embassy, Pusan Korea by L. Burmaster Office of U.S. Northeast Asian Affair )

1953 - Oct 13 - Daiichi-Daihou Maru Incident - the dispute over the Rhee Syngman Line

1953 - Nov 30 - Secret Security Information of USA

1953 - Dec. 9 - SECRET SECURITY INFORMATION by Dulles

1953 - American map made by the National Geographic Society (China Coast and Korea)

1954 - Report of Van Fleet mission to the Far East

1954 - Korean map didn't include Liancourt Rocks ( "Korea: Her History and Culture" Office of Public Information, Republic of Korea.)

1965 - June 22 - Treaty on Basic Relations between Japan and the Republic of Korea

1966 Japanese map from Junior High School Textbook (新詳高等地図 最新版)

1967 - American map showed "Takeshima" as Japanese (a Map of Japan and Korea, Hammond)*

1996 - CIA Map of Japan (Administrative Map of Japan )*

2007 - "The analysis of the western maps" by Funasugi Rikinobu

2008 - New Article on Gerry from San-in Chuo Shinopo(山陰中央新報)

2008 - "10 Issues of Takeshima" by MOFA

2008 - June 25 - Article on the Syngman Rhee Line: Lies, lies, lies "60 Years of the Republic: The Syngman Rhee Line")

2008 - Korean Teacher Union Calls on Japan to Apologize for Dokdo

2008 - June - Japanese News Update

2008 - July 14 - The New Guidelines for Teacher's Handbook

2008 - Aug - New Dokdo Propaganda Video

2008 - Oct. 3 - Japanese Government officially made Cabinet Decision "It is apparent that Takeshima is an inherent part of the territory of Japan."

2008 - Dec. 10 - South Korea' Expansionism/Territorial Ambition never dies.

2008 - Dec. 28 - S. Korea protests Japan's territorial claim to Dokdo

2009 - Feb. 22 - Happy Takeshima Day!

2009 - June. 13 - Former Shimane Gov. Sumita Nobuyoshi (澄田 信義) passed away.

2009 - Nakai Yozaburo Exhibition Mentioned in San-in Chuo Shinopo

2009 - Exhibition on Nakai Yozaburo in Oki from 6/13 - 6/28

2009 - 17 July - Japanese Defense White Paper claimed Takeshima is an inherent part of Japan.

2009 - Oct. 25 - 日韓の和解と友好を考えるマラソントーク (Marathon talk "For Reconciliation and Friendship of Japan-South Korea - )

2010 - Feb. 22 - Happy Takeshima Day !!

2010 - Apr 10 - Japanese Ministry of Education approved all textbooks which mentioned Takeshima as its sovereign territory.

2010 - April 30 - Japanese government approved all textbooks that marked Takeshima as Japanese territory

2010 - May 16 - Foreign Minister of Japan instituted Takeshima Issue to the Foreign Minister of South Korea.

2010 - July 7th - South Korean terrorist attacked Japanese Envoy

2010 - Dokdo Institute of Yeungnam University admits Usando in Choson's official map of Ulleungdo(鬱陵島圖形) in 1711 is Jukdo, not Dokdo/Takeshima.

2011 - Feb 22 - Takeshima Day -- February 22

2011 - Feb 22 - DPJ Lawmakers Attend 'Takeshima Day' Ceremonies

2011 - Feb 22 - S. Koreans Attend Takeshima Day Ceremonies

2011 - Apr 14 - A Looter in the Sea of Japan (Korea plans ocean science research station on Takeshima/Dokdo)

2011 - Jul. 27 - Korean President Bars Japanese Lawmakers from Korea

2011 - Aug.1 - Japanese Politicians Stopped from Leaving Korean Airport

2011 - Aug.3 - Yonhap --"Dokdo ferry operator imposes ban on Japanese passengers"


Series Colum : "Seeking Truth Based Solely on Facts(実事求是)” by Prof. Shimojo Masao(下條正男)

The 26th column “Seeking Truth Based Solely on Facts(実事求是)”

The 25th column “Seeking Truth Based Solely on Facts(実事求是)”

The 24th column “South Korean Government dug their own grave by publishing the English version of "The Dokdo/Takeshima Controversy" by Prof. Emeritus Naito Seichu and Mr. Park Byeong-seop.”


The 23rd column " Refutation against the report of South Korean Yonhap News Agency which misread the Mori Kohan(森幸安)'s "The Map of Tsushima(對馬輿地図)"


The 22th column “ Refutation against "The Meiji Government's recognition of Takeshima=Dokdo" by Mr. Park Byeong-seop(朴炳渉)””, Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4

The 21st column " Refutation against "Analysis of Shimojo Masao's Editorials" by Mr. Park Byeong-seop(朴炳渉)”

The 20th column “Act of Folly by "Northeast Asian History Foundation"”

The 19th column “"Korea Maritime Institute(KMI : 韓国海洋水産開発院), who lacks ability to read their own historical documents, criticized on Shimane Prefecture. "”

The 18th column “Absurd and Peculiar Theory of Prof. Hosaka, plus the "Children and textbook nationwide net 21" and others' Getting "Out of Control.””

The 17th column “The Ordinance of Prime Minister and Cabinet Office, No.24 and the Ordinance of the Ministry of Finance, No.4 in 1951(昭和26年).”

The 16th column ""Dokdo Month" without any historical grounds."

The 15th column " South Korea's Groundless Claim of "Inherent Part of (Korean) Territory"

The 14th column “A reckless Courage of the Professor Kimishima Kazuhiko(君島和彦) of Tokyo Gakugei University(東京学芸大学).

The 13th column “Sins of Asahi Shimbun and Mr. Wakamiya Yoshibumi(若宮啓文).

The 12th column “Northeast Asian History Foundation and Dokdo Research Center's Misunderstanding”

The 11th column “South Korea's Misunderstanding of 'A Map of Three Adjoining Countries (Sangoku Setsujozu 三国接壌図)' by Hayashi Shihei(林子平)”

The 10th column " A Blunder of Sokdo(石島) = Dokto(独島) Theory”

The 9th column "Criticism on Dokdo Research Center”

The 8th column “The Historical Facts" The 6th column “Onshu-shicho-goki (隠州視聴合記)" and the "Nihon Yochi Totei Zenzu (日本輿地路程全図)" by Nagakubo Sekisui(長久保赤水)"

The 5th column “South Korea’s erroneous interpretation of the document 'Takeshima and Another Island are Unrelated to Japan"

The 4th column “Errors in Educational Video Produced by the Northeast Asian History Foundation (東北アジア歴史財団)."

History of San Francisco Peace Treaty

1946 - Jan. 29 - SCAPIN 677
1946 - Feb. 13 - "Conference with GHQ/SCAP concerning separation of the administration"
1946 - Jun. 22 - SCAPIN 1033
1947 - Sep. 16 -SCAPIN 1778
1949 - Nov. 14 - Willam J. Sebald's telegram
1949 - U.S. Maps DOES NOT Confirm Korean Sovereignty Over Dokdo
1949 - Nov. 14 - A letter from W. Walton Butterworth
1949 - Dec. 29 - U.S. Draft made on December 29, 1949
1950 - July - Commentary on Draft Treaty by the Department of State
1950 - Aug. 7 - U.S. Draft made on August 7, 1950
1950 - Oct. 26 - USA Answers to Questions Submitted by the Australian Government
1951 - Apr. - May: Joint UK and USA Draft - extra(1)
1951 - Jun. 1 - New Zealand's view - extra(2)
1951 - Jul. 6 - SCAPIN 2160 (cache)
1951 - Jul. 9 - Coversation of Yu Chan Yang with John F. Dulles
1951 - Jul. 19 - The 2nd Conversation between Yu Chan Yang and John F. Dulles
1951 - Jul. 26 - the Japan-U.S. Joint Committee designated Takeshima as a bombing range for the U.S. Forces stationed in Japan. (official gazette of Japan)
1951 - Aug. 2 - Another letter from You Chan Yang
1951 - Aug.3 - Bogg’s Memorandum (On re-ceiving Boggs's memo. I asked the Korean desk to find out whether anyone in the Korean Embassy officer had told him they believed Dokdo was near Ullengdo, or Takeshima Rock, and suspected that Parangdo was too.)
1951 - Aug. 9 - Rusk's Letter  ( As regards the island of Dokdo, otherwise known as Takeshima or Liancourt Rocks, this normally uninhabited rock formation was according to our information never treated as part of Korea and, since about 1905, has been under the jurisdiction of the Oki Islands Branch Office of Shimane Prefecture of Japan. The island does not appear ever before to have been claimed by Korea. )
1951 - Sep. 9 - San Francisco Peace Treaty
1951 - Sep. 21 - Korean Government comprehended Takeshima/Dokdo was affirmed as a Japanese Territory in Peace Treaty
1952- Jan. 18 - Syngman Rhee Line
1950's - Japan & Korea Argue Their Claims in 1950s Letters
1952 - Nov. 5 - Confidential Security Information of USA ("It appears that the Department has taken the position that these rocks belong to Japan and has so informed the Korean Ambassador in Washington." )
1952 - Dec. 4 - Confidential Security Information of USA ( "I much appreciate your letter of November 14 in regard to the status of the Dokdo Island (Liancourt Rocks). The information you gave us had never been previously available to the Embassy. We had never heard of Deen Rusk’s letter to the Korean Ambassador in which the Department took a definite stand on this question.")
1953 Jul. 22 - Confidential Security Information of USA “Possible Methods of Resolving Liancourt Rocks Dispute between Japan and ROK”( The United States Government's understanding of the territorial status of this island was stated in assistant Secretary dated August 10,1951.")
1953 - Jul 22 - US Doc. Reconfirms Dean Rusk Letter (Letter from Office of Northeast Asian Affairs To E. Allan Lightner American Embassy, Pusan Korea by L. Burmaster Office of U.S. Northeast Asian Affair )
1953 - Nov. 30 - Secret Security Information of USA ("The Liancourt Rocks case appears to have aspects in common with that of Shikotan Island" "Remind the ROK of our previous statement of view (the Rusk letter)")
1953 - Dec. 9 - SECRET SECURITY INFORMATION by Dulles
1953 - Oct 13 - Daiichi-Daihou Maru Incident - the dispute over the Rhee Syngman Line
1954 - Aug. - Report of Van Fleet mission to the Far East, 26 April - 7 August , 1954
2008 - Jul. 30 - Press Briefing by Senior Director for Asian Affairs at the National Security Council, Dennis Wilder, on President's Trip to Asia (cache)


Others

Should Japanese Boycott Ulleungdo?

"Korea bans entry of Japanese reps on Ulleung foray"

Should Japanese Lawmakers Be Barred from Visiting Dokdo Museum?

Why are Koreans afraid of Japanese lawmakers visiting Ulleungdo?

"Seoul in Quanary Over Japanese Lawmakers" Planned Visit to Dokdo Museum

Which country will China try to occupy first, Taiwan or North Korea?

The Reason Japan Cannot Give Up Takeshima (Dokdo)

Why Did Koreans Fail to Mention Imperial Edict #41 to the US in 1951?

Arirang: "Korean Lawmakers Hold Seminar of Dokdo"

Ulleung County Symbol Recognizes 'Three Peaks' of Ulleungdo

Video Comparing Korean Map Drawings of "Usando" (于山島), by Yabutarou

Dong-a Reports Discovery of a "Dae Dongyeojido" Map Showing "Dokdo"

Steve Barber is back in the Korean news.

Heartbreaking Earthquake & Tsunami in Japan

"'Flash Patriotism'--Dokdo Bonds Gone After 5 Years"

Problem with Blogger's SPAM Filtering

Daum Map's "Jukdo" (죽도 - 竹島)

Some New Gadgets Added to the Blog

Page Views for This Blog for Feb. 3 - Feb. 9


Exhibition of "Dokdo" Maps & Docs in Busan

Samcheok Museum Map dated 1884 - 1888?

Joseon Paldo Jido (朝鮮八道地圖) - Ulleungdo (鬱陵島)

Are Koreans still interested in "Dokdo"?

Korean Finally "Discovers" 1905 Japanese Newspaper Article

I do not support Korea's "East Sea" movement.

"Rie Akiba angers Korean netizens with Dokdo"

"Rename Dokdo 'Syngman Rhee Islets'"

Famous Movie Quotes about Dokdo

"Hokkaido Teachers Support Korea Over Dokdo"

"Japan Takes Softer Stance Over Dokdo"?

How should 三數十里 (삼수십리) be translated?

How should 大東輿地圖 be translated in English?

Nat'l Library of Korea "Map Materials Room" Opens

Columbia Univ. Professor: "Kim Jeong-ho had absolutely no concept of Dokdo"

Old Maps at the National Library of Korea

U. of Wisconsin Library Removes "Dok Do" from Map Description

Univ. of Wisconsin at Milwaukee Duped by "Dokdo" Advocates

Important Mistranslation of 1694 Ulleungdo Inspection Report

Congnamul's Satellite Photo of Ulleungdo

Man Arrested for Planning to Torch Japanese Embassy

What happened to our "hit counter"?

Is the Dokdo-Takeshima debate still alive in Japan?

Yuji Hosaka: "Born to Defend Korea's Dokdo Claim"

"Lesson Learned From Dokdo," by Tong Kim

Mark Selden seems ignorant of Dokdo/Takeshima history

"Dokdo Humor," by Gerry Bevers

Dokdo Museum Exhibition Focuses on Modern History

"Seoul Podcast" Discusses Dokdo

Another EPIK-sponsored Dokdo Brainwashing

Jukdo (竹島) Missing from Daum's Satellite Photo of Ulleungdo

Ulleungdo's Neighboring Island of Jukdo (죽도 - 竹島)

Foreign English Teachers Used for Dokdo Propaganda

New Survey: Is the Korean government telling its people the truth about Liancourt Rocks (Dokdo)?

Survey: Int'l Court Should Settle Dokdo-Takeshima Dispute

A Sea Lion Cave

Steve Barber & his "Academic" Site in Korean News

Some good photos of Liancourt Rocks (Takeshima 竹島 / Dokdo 獨島)

KBS NEWS: "Dokdo Protector 'An Yong-bok Foundation' Sets Sail"

English Web Sites Supporting Japan's View on Liancourt Rocks?

[Viewpoint] "Spreading the word about Dokdo"

Ulleungdo Inspectors' "Wind-waiting House" (待風軒) Over 158 Years Old

"Difficult to confirm" if Korea Burned Ulleungdo Inspection Documents

The Korean "wild cat" (삵, 살쾡이, 野猫)

Korean Documentary on "Dokdo"

Japan makes a protest stealthily

Great Pictures of Liancourt Rocks on "The Boston Globe" Site

US Think Tank Warns Seoul about Noisy Dokdo Protests

An Yong-bok's "Usando" (于山島) probably "Ika-shima" (いか嶋)

Another Ridiculous Claim from Hosaka Yuji

Korean Translation of Jang Han-sang's 1694 Inspection Record

RAS Will Sponsor a Lecture on Dokdo on Feb. 24

"Old Japanese Document Shows Dokdo Is Korean Territory"

Korean Dokdo Documentary Flopping at Theaters

A Korean Song: "Do you know Dokdo Island?"

Review of Korean Documentary, "Sorry, Dokdo"

"New high school draft curriculum avoids islets row"

Integrity finally wins one

Has Toron Talker changed sites?

Dong-A Ilbo Archive Database

The Takeshima Secret Pact

"S. Korean Lawmakers to Visit Washington Over Dokdo Issue"

"독도" by Gerry Bevers

Essay Contest on Dokdo

Kim Jang-Hoon bought maps

North Korean Stamp of Dokdo

Has the Dokdo Guardian stopped guarding Dokdo?

"Addressing Japan's Dokdo Disease," by Kang Chun-suk"

Korea Protests the Mention of "Dokdo" in Japan's Defense "White Paper"

New Poll: How should the dispute over Liancourt Rocks (Dokdo/Takeshima) be settled?

"Google Earth": Great Satellite Photo of Jukdo

"Korea Times" Distorting Facts

Reuters: "S. Korea steps up defense of disputed islets"

KT: "Japan Renews Claim to Dokdo in Defense White Paper"

NYT: "Desolate Dots in the Sea Stir Deep Emotions as South Korea Resists a Japanese Claim"

IHT: "A fierce Korean pride in a lonely group of islets"

AP: "SKorean emotions run high over island dispute"

Steve Barber in Korean News

How about a trade?

"Projects Unveiled to Reinforce Sovereignty Over Dokdo"

Professor Claims Korea's National Institute of Korean History Mistranslated 1714 Passage

Interview with Mark Lovmo about his Dokdo Site

Same photo, different effects?

"Dokdo is Korean Territory"?

CIA - The World Factbook

Korean Times: "Dokdo Research Institute Opens"

Wow! Even More Ridiculous Claims.

More Ridiculous Dokdo Claims from a Shameless Lee Sang-tae

A New Version of the Dokdo Song?

Does Japan also have a Takeshima song?

Another Picture of the Map Mural at the "Blue House"

Full Text of Bush-Lee Joint Press Conference

"70% of Japanese Think Dokdo is Theirs: Poll"

President Bush: "I know Dokdo Island."

"US Reinstates S. Korean Sovereignty Over Dokdo"

Today, visits to this blog passed 1 million.

"Lee, Bush to Discuss Dokdo"

"US Office No Longer Regards Dokdo as Korean Territory"

Ulleungdo from Possibly Samcheok (三陟) or Donghae City (東海)

Ampontan Compares Kor & Jpn Editorials on the Current Dispute

Ampontan on Korea's Reaction to the Current Takeshima Controversy

In the Process of Changing the Blog Menu

Links to Some Great Copies of Ulleungdo Maps

They insist that Tsushima was Korean territory

Comments will now be moderated.

New, old map of Ulleungdo?

Japanese Video Disputing Korean Claim Usando Was "Dokdo"

"Anonymous" comments are no longer allowed.

News Flash - PM Fukuda notified President Lee of describing Takeshima

Japanese News Update : July 11, 2008

Korean Eastern limits described in various books world wide exclude Takeshima/Dokdo from Korean Territory

Article on the Syngman Rhee Line: Lies, lies, lies.

Japanese News Update : June 26, 2008

San-in Chuo Shimpo: "Usando (于山島) = Jukdo (竹嶼), Documented for the First Time" (日省錄)

Japanese Ministry of Education : "Takeshima Japanese soil, Teachers handbook to say isles claimed by Tokyo, Seoul belong to Japan" (Yomiuri Shimbun : 読売新聞)

Japanese Documentary on Dokdo-Takeshima Dispute ( TSK Super News Special : TSKスーパーニューススペシャル「鬱陵島で見た!~竹島・溝は埋まったか~」)

Korean Fishing Boat Seized by Japanese Patrol Boat (May 18 report on Korea's MBC News)

Korea Times: "Teacher's Guidebook Alleges Japan to Claim Dokdo"

A Russian businessman published a book for appealing restoration of four islands of Kuril to Japan.

Are Google & Korea conspiring to hide "Jukdo" (竹島)?

Korean news site displays childish nationalism.

Korean Teacher Union Calls on Japan to Apologize for Dokdo

Did Koreans elect another lamebrain president?

Japan's Immature Relations with China & S. Korea

Link to Pictures & Info on Ulleungdo & "Dokdo"

Good Satellite Image of Ulleungdo

Great Copy of Bak Seok-chang's 1711 Map of Ulleungdo

Teaching English with Dokdo Propaganda

Japanese Government Bows to Korea on Takeshima

Strangely, votes are being subtracted from our survey.

Roh Moo-hyun's Angry Dokdo Speech

President Lee's policy on Korean-Japanese history is the right policy.

"Japan Claims Dokdo in Foreign Ministry Document"

Korean Eastern limits described in various books exclude Takeshima/Dokdo from Korean Territory

Korea to Use "National Geographic" to Publicize Dokdo Sovereignty

Takeshima Not Mentioned in Japanese Educational Guidelines

Any Info on this Japanese Map (實測朝鮮全圖, 1894, 宗孟寬)?

Some Interesting Photos of Ulleungdo

Samcheok Museum's "Ulleungdo Dohyeong"

Samcheok Museum's "Ulleungdo Dohyeong" (鬱陵島圖形)

Is Mark Lovemo's "Dokdo" Web site history?

Over 40 Old Korean Maps on Display in Suwon

Happy Takeshima Day !

Surely you are joking, Prof. Hosaka ! (ご冗談でしょう、保坂先生!)

Wikipedia Drops "History" Section from Liancourt Rocks Description

Dong-A Ilbo: "Japanese Netizens Actively Promote 'Takeshima'"

Yomiuri Shimbun: "Detailed map of Takeshima completed"

2007 - "Takeshima in the Korean official map" by Funasugi Rikinobu (舩杉力修) - Supplement

Korea to add "Dokdo" to image of old map.

Korean Nationalism and so-called "Dokdo"

Geographical Survey Institute of Japan(国土地理院) first displays Takeshima's details in the topographical map.

Korea's NE Asian History Foundation Advertisement

Some "Netizens" Upset New Banknote Has No Dokdo

1894-1948 Korean territory (Revised version)

Good Video of Ulleungdo's Northern Shore

Went to Samcheok Museum today, and....

Can you see "Dokdo" (獨島) from Ulleungdo?

Korean Scholar Says "Usando" Was Ulleungdo's "Jukdo"

Article on "Dokdo Islands" in "Vladivostok News"

"Onshu Shicho Goki" - The different translations

Oh, no, Dokdo. Here we go, again.

KBS Documentary on "Jukdo," the Real Usando

Daum Urges Koreans to Come Here and Vote "Dokdo"

Inspector's Map of Ulleungdo Shows Jasando (子山嶋)?

Some help with this map, please?

Why did Western Maps Show Ulleungdo as Japanese?

Symposium on "The Life of Dokdo Guardian An Yong-bok"

Where have all the Usandos gone?

Nice picture of Ulleungdo's Jukdo (Usando)

Today's Update September 02, 2007

What do イガ島, まの島 and マノ島, have in common?

Most Popular Article on Sanin-chou Shimpo site?

"Dokdo Must Have Trees to be Internationally Legal Island"

Yonhap News says Dokdo was annexed in 1910

ALERT: Dokdo Under Attack!

Investigation of Japanese maps during Meiji period before the incorporation of Liancourt rocks

General Comments for Suggestions for June 2007

Japanese Articles on Dokdo/Takeshima

Japanese Name Glossary

Japanese Document and Map Links

English/Western Document and Map Links

Korean Document and Map Links

Wikipedia Switches from "Dokdo" to "Liancourt Rocks"

Dokdo Residents Talk about the Islets

"Shimane Prefecture Research Committee Report 'Takeshima is Japanese Land'"

Searching for Solutions or Cheerleaders?


韓国語での投稿記事(年代順)(Blog Articles in Korean)

竹島の歴史入門(日本語版)・Historyof Dokdo for beginners (Korean version)

한국의 친구서,부디 검토해 주십시오


Index of Related Articles on Occidentalism (オクシデンタリズムでの投稿)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video Series (With Japanese Translations) :

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 1 : Propaganda video, 朝鮮王朝実録, 八道総図 (1530)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 2 : 世祖実録 (1457年4月16日 世祖三年丁丑四月)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 3 : 1786 Ulleungdo Inspection : 日省録(1786), 海東地圖(1750 c.a.), 鬱陵島外圖(1882)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 4 : 1794 Ulleungdo Inspection "Gajido (가지도) and more dead sea lions"

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 4 Supplement : "Sea Lions & More Proof Usando was not “Dokdo”" 1786&1794 Inspection, 皇城新聞(1899)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 5 : "The King, Lee Gyu-won & Many Names for a Neighboring Island" 高宗19年(1882), 靑邱圖(1834), 英海軍地図(1863), 大日本国沿海略図(1867), 「松島開拓之議」(1877/8), 軍艦「天城」作成地図(1880)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 6 : 海東地圖(1750's), 靑邱圖(1834), 韓国古地図(1800's), 鬱陵島外圖(1882), 日本古地図(1886), 鬱陵島見取図(1905), 韓国水産誌「鬱陵島全図」(1909)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 7 : Google Earth, 韓国古地図集, 大韓全図(1899), Histoire de l’Eglise de Coree(1874)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 8 : "An Yong-bok, Usando, & Matsushima (Songdo)" 肅宗実録(1696), 鬱陵島圖形(1711), 鬱陵島事蹟(1694), 海東地圖(1750s), 輿地圖(1736-67), 朝鮮地圖(1750-1768), 地乘(1776-1800), 東國文獻備考(1770), 日省録(1793), 萬機要覽(1808), 靑邱圖(1835), 朝鮮国交際始末内探書(1869), 高宗実録(1882), 鬱陵島外圖(1882), 大韓全図(1899), 皇城新聞(1899), 大韓勅令勅令第41号(1900)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 9 : "Location of Usando Unknown in 1903 and 1913" 毎日新報(1913)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 10 : “Usando and Ulleungdo Are 350 ri to the East” 增補 文獻備考(1908), 大韓勅令第四一號(1900), 皇城新聞(1899)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Part 11 : 大韓全図(1899), 大韓新地誌(1907), 崔南善「朝鮮常識問答」(1946) 「朝鮮常識」(1948)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 1 : 靑邱圖(1834), Google Earth, 鬱陵島地図

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 2 : "1882 Ulleungdo, an outside view & Seal Cave" 鬱陵島外圖(1882)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 2 Supplement : "可支島, 石間朱穴" 鬱陵島外圖(1882), 日省録(1786), 文獻備考

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 3 : "Haedongjido (海東地圖): Ulleungdo, Usando, and Sea Lions" 海東地圖(1750 c.a.)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 4 : "Maps Showing Ulleungdo/Usando 2 Days from Uljin" 輿地圖 (1730ca. ), 海東地圖(1750 c.a.), 左海地図(Jwahaejido)江原道図(1710年)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 5 : "Muleungdo (Ullengdo) “also called ‘Usan’” 東輿備攷(1682ca.)輿地圖 (ca. 1730), 地海東地圖(Early 1750s), 朝鮮地圖(1750 - 1768), 地乘(After 1776), 廣輿圖(early 19th century), 靑邱圖(1834)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 6 : "1894 Japanese Map of Korea (Ulleungdo & Usando) " 朝鮮全図(1894)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 7 : 鬱陵島圖形(ca. 1711)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 8 : 備邊司 方眼地圖(ca. 1750)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 9 : "1877 Japanese Map Showing “Usando” (于山島)" 原版朝鮮全図之写(1877)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 10 : 朝鮮國細見全図(1874)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 11 : 大朝鮮國全圖(1890s)

Lies, Half-truths, and Dokdo Video, Maps 12 : 日本帝国海軍作成 朝鮮全図(1873)


Other Related Posts : Occidentalism

Wikipedia Switches from “Dokdo” to “Liancourt Rocks” : Tuesday, May 29th, 2007

Chosun Ilbo: “Danger of Dokdo Disappearing from Wikipedia” : Thursday, May 24th, 2007

Historical Distortion or Ignorance? : Friday, April 27th, 2007

Has anyone been to this museum? : Thursday, April 26th, 2007

Shimane Prefecture’s New English Pamphlet on Takeshima : Wednesday, April 25th, 2007

Japan’s MOFA Updates Takeshima Web Pages : Monday, April 23rd, 2007

Interview with Sankei Shimbun Reporter on Dokdo/Takeshima : Sunday, April 22nd, 2007

An Yong-bok: “We arrived at Oki’s Matsushima….”? : Sunday, March 25th, 2007

Dokdo Museum Head Admits Maps Show “Jukdo, not Dokdo” : Tuesday, March 20th, 2007

New Article on Usando & “Haejang” Bamboo : Tuesday, March 13th, 2007

Cutouts from an 1896 Japanese Map : Saturday, March 10th, 2007

Artistic License in Regard to “Dokdo”? : Friday, March 9th, 2007

The other article about Gerry in the San-In Chuo Shinpou : Tuesday, February 27th, 2007

Korean History Group Responds to Japanese Article on Usando : Saturday, February 24th, 2007

Happy Takeshima Day! : Wednesday, February 21st, 2007

New Takeshima (Dokdo) Article in Japanese Newspaper : Wednesday, February 21st, 2007

Gojong & Sunjong Added to Choson Annals : Thursday, January 25th, 2007

Another Picture of “Dokdo” from Ulleungdo? : Thursday, January 18th, 2007 (1454年 世宗実録「地理志」)

Developing a Dokdo/Takeshima database : Wednesday, January 10th, 2007

The Korea Times runs Gerry’s story : Sunday, January 7th, 2007

Shimane Prefecture Takeshima Research Group Crushes Korea’s Dokdo claims : Monday, December 4th, 2006

Another problematic article in the Korean media : Thursday, November 30th, 2006

Asked Not to Write About Dokdo on the Net : Wednesday, November 15th, 2006

The lies of the Dokdo Museum : Wednesday, July 26th, 2006

Gerry Bevers writes about Dokdo/Takeshima : Wednesday, May 10th, 2006

Other Related Posts : Enjoy Korea/Japan on Naver

International Law
国際法で有効な韓国の竹島実行支配の証拠を教えてください

国際法に基づく韓国の竹島の実効支配の証拠は見つかりましたか?

判例で読み解く竹島の領有権

日本の1905年の竹島編入は、秘密裏に軍事的に実施したから違法ニダ。

竹島は無主地でなかったので、日本の1905年の先占は無効である。

当時国際法は領土編入の前提に (1) 茂朱誌と (2)茂朱誌の場合にもその周辺関連国への問い合わせと国際的考試を条件にし

拝啓 韓国明知大学教授(国際法) 金明基 殿

国際法の学者は、先占の通知義務を認めている。1905年の竹島編入は無効nida。

竹島の先占には、通知が必要とか、官報公告が必要とか、嘘をつくなよ。

1905年の竹島編入は軍事目的のため無効?

1905年の竹島編入は無効?国際法を捏造する学者 明知大学教授 金明基 その2

1905年の竹島編入は無効?国際法を捏造する学者 明知大学教授 金明基


竹島は、紛争地ではない!!!

国際司法裁判所で対馬の領有権を争おう!!!


安龍福は、嘘吐きなので処罰した。


SCAPIN677で竹島が韓国領になった?詐欺国家の嘘を暴く

日本はSCAPIN第677号を無視している!!!

アメリカも韓国のSCAPIN解釈を拒否

ラスク書簡の法的効力。竹島は日本領でした

ラスク書簡を否定する文書の解読

ラスク書簡を否定する文書が見つかったんだって?


太政官文書の国際法上の効力を考える。

いつ日本が竹島の権原(title)を放棄しましたか?

サンフランシスコ条約で、日本は竹島のtitleを放棄した?


韓国が、竹島の国際司法裁判所への付託を拒否する理由

国際法の権威Crawford教授が、「日韓併合条約は合法」と結論



Maps/Documents

韓国が隠している竹島の歴史 半万年

1905年以前に竹島が韓国領だった証拠はどこ?

韓国人は、これが竹島に見えるの?

于山島は、鬱稜島の西にある島です!!(ちなみに、竹島は鬱稜島の東南)

成宗実録の三峯島の解釈(韓国国史編纂委員会の歪曲)

太政官文書の「里」は4kmではなく、海里(1.85km)ニダ。

これが、大韓帝国が竹島を実効支配した証拠nida。 (独島で取ったあしか日本輸出)

太政官文書の「外一島」は、竹島なのか?

SF条約に馬羅島は書いてないが韓国領だ。よって、竹島も韓国領だ。

保坂が公開した独島地図

竹島の存在を知らなかったのに、大韓帝国は実効支配してたのですか?

韓国の竹島には、翼がついていたのですか?

鬱陵島から竹島が見えると、「東国輿地勝覧」にも書いてある。

1877年に日本と関係なしとした「竹島外一島」とは、鬱陵島と竹嶼(CHUKDO)のことでした。

于山島は竹島ではなく、架空の島でした。

サンフランシスコ条約1949年12月の米国草案で竹島を日本領と規定。

アメリカが「竹島は日本領」と、韓国大使に最終回答 (1951年7月19日  韓国大使(ヤン)から国務長官への書簡/1951年8月10日 国務次官補(ラスク)から韓国大使への回答)

1899年の大韓全図で、竹島を韓国領とはっきり明記

EEZの竹島起点は韓国に不利?

竹島の領有権について日韓の主張を比較検証

【海洋調査】国内法では拿捕可能、国際法では不可

半島の史書で検証する竹島。

2. 外国の地図だけで決めるなら、鬱陵島も日本の領土

3. 林子平圖のTakeshimaは竹島/独島ではない

1903年日本で発刊された世界地理教科書に

于山島は竹嶼Jukdoか独島か?

8. 19世紀末大韓帝国政府, 独島・鬱陵島を韓国領土で正確に表示 という韓国の主張は歪曲

19世紀末も、鬱陵島の最も顕著な付属島はJUKDOで、次に顕著な島は観音島

金正浩 1834.靑邱圖(写本)中の于山島

于山島が竹島/独島でない10の理由

Naver Mapで見比べる 大于島と小于島、JUKDOと観音島

鬱陵島の北東部に有るJukdo竹嶼の地図と、 郡県図に記入された于山島の地図を比べてみる

18.19C前後の鬱陵島及びLiancourt Rock付近の漁業

1899年の大韓全図の鬱陵島の描写の疑問

2008- July 14 - The New Guidelines for Teacher's Handbook

Japanese government decided to describe "Takeshima" in a teachers's handbook on the new curriculum guidelines for middles school social studies, finally !! Yesterday's article from Yomiuri Shimbun cache

Teaching handbook set to mention Takeshima

The Yomiuri Shimbun

The government has begun discussions over how to refer to the disputed Takeshima islets in a handbook on the new curriculum guidelines for middle school social studies, but is expected to stop short of referring to them explicitly as part of "the nation's territory," The Yomiuri Shimbun learned Saturday.

Once a final decision over the description has been reached, the Education, Science and Technology Ministry plans to present the handbook to prefectural boards of education officials at a meeting to be held in Tokyo on Monday to explain the handbook.

The ministry initially planned to describe the islets as "inherent territory of Japan" in the new manual.

But after a strong response from South Korea, some within the government argued Japan should give greater consideration to maintaining good bilateral relations.

The government has been consulting with relevant departments over a plan to mention in the new teaching manual the islets as an example of the country's ongoing territorial disputes, which along with the four islands off eastern Hokkaido, known as the northern territories, are required to be studied.

On the northern territories, the ministry plans to say, "The Habomai islets and the Shikotan, Kunashiri and Etorofu islands are the inherent territory of Japan and illegally occupied by Russia."

In the case of the Takeshima islets, known as Dokdo in South Korea, the ministry has discussed a proposal to mention in the manual that Seoul claims sovereignty over them.

New editions of handbooks on the curriculum guidelines are drawn up for each subject at primary, middle and high schools when the guidelines are revised, about every 10 years.

As the manuals give detailed explanations about the content of the guidelines, they are also used for publishers producing textbooks.

Currently, only four of the 14 publishers mention the Takeshima islets in their textbooks for social studies classes at middle school.

However, the introduction of the description about the islets in the new handbook is expected to prompt more publishers to mention them.
(Jul. 13, 2008)


The Takeshima part of new guidlines for teacher's handbook is as follows. I don't have much time to translate all of them. But the lines in red are Takeshima related part and translation is in orange. Honestly, it sounds very reasonable and nothing confrontational against Korea. I think there should be description about Korean illegal occupancy and it's logical breakdown, and Japanese government did backed a lot. But it is better than nothing. Especially, it is really good to hear PM Fukuda, who had been indecisive, did stand firm against Korean president. Korean should stay calm and need to understand this was just a due course which had already been decided two years ago. And they also need to understand Japan has its right to teach kids what they need to do just like Korean are doing. Read more from Choson Ilbo.

本年3月の中学校学習指導要領の改訂を受けた、2012年度から使用される中学校学習指導要領「解説」における竹島の取り扱いについて、内閣官房長官と文部科学大臣との間で論争になっていたことにつき、文部科学省は解説における記述について、本日午後、次の様に発表した。

○ 中学校学習指導要領 社会[地理的分野]
 「領域の特色と変化」については、北方領土が我が国の固有の領土であることなど、我が国の領域をめぐる問題にも着目させるようにすること。

(※ 平成10年12月告示の現行のままで変更なし)

○ 解説
改訂版(Revised) 現行(Now in use)
 (略)…。また、我が国は四面環海の国土であるため直接他国と陸地を接していないことに着目させ、国境がもつ意味について考えさせたり、我が国が正当に主張している立場に基づいて、当面する領土問題や経済水域の問題などに着目させたりすることも大切である。  その際、「北方領土が我が国の固有の領土であることなど、我が国の領域をめぐる問題にも着目させるようにすること」(内容の取扱い)とあることから、北方領土(歯舞群島、色丹島、国後島、択捉島)については、その位置と範囲を確認させるとともに、北方領土は我が国の固有の領土であるが、現在ロシア連邦によって不法に占拠されているため、その返還を求めていることなどについて、的確に扱う必要がある。また、我が国と韓国の間に竹島をめぐって主張に相違があることなどにも触れ、北方領土と同様に我が国の領土・領域について理解を深めさせることも必要である。 (Northern territories (Etorofu island, Kunashiri island, Shikotan island and Habomai islands of Kuril Islands)“ are our inherent territory, they are illegally occupied by Russia.) It is necessary to deepen understanding about our country's territory in a way identical with the Northern territories by mentioning that there exist differing assertions between our country and Korea over Takeshima.  (略)…。なお、我が国は四面環海の国土であるため直接他国と陸地を接して いないことに着目させ、国境がもつ意味について考えさせたり、我が国が当面する領土問題や経済水域の問題などに着目させたりすることも大切である。 その 際、「北方領土が我が国の固有の領土であることなど、我が国の領域をめぐる問題にも着目させるようにすること」(内容の取扱い)とあることから、北方領土 (歯舞諸島、色丹島、国後島、択捉島)については、その位置と範囲を確認させるとともに、北方領土は我が国の固有の領土であるが、現在ロシア連邦によって占拠されているため、その返還を求めていることなどについて、我が国が正当に主張している立場に基づいて的確に扱う必要がある。

13.7.08

News Flash - PM Fukuda notified President Lee of describing Takeshima

PM Fukuda had already notified President Lee Japanese government decided to describe Takeshima in the manual for the teachers' guideline
Sankei(産経新聞) cache 2008.7.13 01:53

On 12th, it is revealed that Prime Minister Fukuda Yasuo of Japan had already told the government's policy of describing Takeshima clearly in the guidebook for teachers's guide book for manual of new junior high school social studies as "Territory of Japan", to President Lee Myung-bak during the Japan-South Korea presidential talk held at the summit in the Hokkaido Toyako on the ninth. Political sources clarified it. A expression is considered to be still under moderation.

After the conference with Chief Cabinet Secretary Machimura Nobutaka yesterday, Tokai Kisaburo(渡海紀三朗文部科学相), minister of education, culture, sports, science and technology, told the press that it is still under the process of decision(調整中) wether describing it clearly or not .

Political sources emphasize the resolution for oppsing description, the South Korea Diet adopted, made Japanese government could not avoid describing it clearly (in order to claim sovereignty either).

12.7.08

1928 - The name of Kwannondo(観音島) came from the "Stone Buddhas (石仏)" on the island.

Mr. Sugino(杉野洋明), who found 1906's Korean news paper article, which omits Dokdo from Uldo County (皇城新聞 「鬱島郡의 配置顛末」) found new hint for the identity of 石島(Seokdo) in Imperial Edict No.41 in 1900 (大韓勅令第41号) .

According to the article he found this time, there were some Buddha shaped stones (石仏) on Kwannondo(観音島) , and it was started to be called the island as "観音島" later.

As you know, 観音(Kwannon), or 観音菩薩(Bodhisattva Avalokitesvara) is one of the Bodhisattva(菩薩). Technically, Bodhisattva is different from Buddha(仏) itself, but it is sometimes used as one of Buddhas.

Read more about the article : ★大韓帝国勅令41号の「石島」の正体は・・・(Japanese.)

1928年9月、東亜日報が鬱陵島の特集

11.7.08

Japanese News Update : July 11, 2008

July 11, 20:40 - "Fukuda Yasuo, Prime Minister of Japan, told that the issue is still under discussion among ministries concerned, and it will be decided by taking every factor into consideration." - 時事通信(Jiji Press) (cache)

July 11 - "Tokai Kisaburo(渡海紀三朗文部科学相), minister of education, culture, sports, science and technology, claimed Territory is a Base for the Nation. " - 産経新聞(Sankei Shimbun) (cache) , 読売新聞(Yomiuri Shimbun), 山陰中央新報(San-in Chuo Shimpo)
"Tokai Kisaburo(渡海紀三朗文部科学相), minister of education, culture, sports, science and technology, claimed "Territory is a Base for the Nation." The minister discussed the issue with Chief Cabinet Secretary Machimura Nobutaka(町村信孝官房長官) at Prime Minister's Office and explained the necessity for teaching students the standpoint of Japan and the concern from the aspect of education if it would be put off. Mr. Machimura expressed the diplomatic concern about the influence on the six-parties talks over the nuclear issue with North Korea, though he didn't order anything. Mr. Tokai told it is still under the process of decision(調整中) and the decision would be made around a day before 14th this month."

July 11, 12:26 - "The final decision is up to Prime Minister's overall consideration, Tokai Kisaburo(渡海紀三朗文部科学相), minister of education, culture, sports, science and technology explained" - 共同通信社(Kyodo Press) , 産経新聞(Sankei), 毎日新聞(Mainichi)

July 11 12:25 - "It is Japan who decide, the Foreign Minister claimed." - 時事通信(Jiji Press) cache
The Foreign Minister Kohmura Masahiko (高村正彦外相) told press that he expressed that describing Takeshima in the new course of study manual of the junior high school social studies clearly or not is to be decided by Japan, in the Japan-South Korea foreign ministerial meeting on the eighth.

July 10 - "Shimane Prefecture strongly demand "Sovereignty over Takeshima" to be clearly described in the manual" - 中国新聞(Chugoku Shimbun) cache, 山陰中央新報(San-in Chuo Shimpo) cache
The parties concerned in Shimane prefecture , including the "League of assembly member for establishment of Takeshima's territorial sovereignty in Shimane(竹島領土権確立島根県議会議員連盟)", a Governor Mizoguchi Zenbee(溝口善兵衛) and acting secretary general Hosoda Hiroyuki(細田博之自民党幹事長代理) of the Liberal-Democratic Party who is a representative of of Shimane 1election district including Okinoshima town, which the island belongs to, strongly demanded Japanese Government not to overturn or reconsider describing Takeshima clearly in the manual for teachers.

July 6 - (Editorial)"Japanese government still in consideration of describing Takeshima clearly in the teacher's manual or not. " - 産経新聞(Sankei Shimbun)

June 13 - "Korean Protesters damaged the door of Consulate General of Japan in Pusan" - 産経新聞(Sankei Shimbun) cache
"Korean protesters against Japanese decision of describing the sovereignty over Takeshima in the new teacher's manual, damaged the door of Consulate General of Japan in Pusan. The Japanese Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology in Japan received the report, and the South Korea police authorities clarified it on the 13th. Japan is requesting a thorough investigation and the relapse prevention from South Korea. The group composes of the former North Korea agent provocateur and it's bereaved families, according to parties concerned. One person beat the door with the hammer when rallying against in the doorway. "

9.7.08

1894 Japanese map "日清韓三国地図"

This map, which was edited by Shimizu Jotaro (Kyoto), printed by Nakada Sadanori (Osaka) and published by Nakamura Yoshimatsu (Osaka), was put on sale in Japan by Shobido (鍾美堂) in August 1894, just after the beginning of Sino-Japanese War . The title of the map is "日清韓三国地図" which means "A map of three countries, Japan, Qing and Korea".


The map called "朝鮮輿地図" (Map of Chosun) was made by the same staff just one month before (July 1894). So there is no new information here - both of two islands, 竹島 (Takeshima) and 松島 (Matsushima), can be seen as same as in the "朝鮮輿地図".
Both of two islands seem to be not coloured, while Korea was painted in light green and Japan was painted in light pink. Some of the Japanese and Korean islands, such as Yakushima (Japan) and Geojedo (巨済島, Korea), were not coloured too. So uncoloured islands didn't always mean they didn't belong to Japan or Korea.
The good point of this map is that you can read the longitudinal lines in the map. The island labeled as 竹島 (Takeshima) lies at about 130 degree E which means that it is no other than Argonaut Island (129 degree 50' E). 松島 (Matsushima) is located at about 131 degree E, which is definitely Dagelet Island or Ulleungdo (130 degree 56' E). Unfortunately Liancourt Rocks were not drawn. However, the locations of these islands are quite similar to those in the western maps of the 19th century. That means "Taka I" or "Takeshima"in the western maps from the 19th century is the same as "竹島 (Takeshima)" in Japanese maps in the same era and that is Argonaut island (phantom island). Also it means "Matsu I" or "Matsushima" in the western maps is the same as "松島 (Matsushima)" in Japanese maps, and that is Dagelet Island (Ulleungdo).

Pro-Korean people used to insist that "Japan admitted that Liancourt Rocks belonged to Korea" showing the map called "新撰朝鮮国全図" (Newly Edited Whole Map of Chosun Country), which was made in the same year (1894). (Please look at the following article.)


They used to insist that Matsushima in the map is Liancourt Rocks but it's not true.

7.7.08

1817 Aaron Arrowsmith's map of Japan and Von Siebold

Aaron Arrowsmith (1750-1823) was an English geographer (mapmaker) and member of the Arrowsmith family of geographers. His maps were very numerous, and the neatness and finished style gained a very extensive reputation, but his maps contain many great and important errors.
Here is his map of Japan which was published in 1817. The credit at the bottom of the map reads "Drawn by A. Arrowsmith.", "Published., 1817, by A. Constable & Co. Edinburgh." and "Engraved by Sid.y.Hall."

There are two islands in the Sea of Japan; "Argonaut I." and "I. Dagelet", both of which were discovered in 1789 and 1787 respectively. Liancourt Rocks were not drawn, as the rocks were yet to be discovered until 32 years later.
Although this map is not related with Liancourt Rocks, it has an important meaning.

The year 1817 was the 14th year of Bunka in Japan, literally Edo period and six years after, in 1823, Philpp Franz von Siebold (1796-1866) arrived in Nagasaki, Japan. Von Siebold focused on study of Japanese fauna and flora while he gave lectures on Japanese young scientists and medical students during his stay. In 1828 he went to Edo (today's Tokyo) collecting many plants and animals and during the journey he got some detailed maps of Japan drawn by Inoh Tadataka but posession of such maps were strictly forbidden. He was accused of posessing them and expelled from Japan in 1829. Most importantly, he may have had a chance to see the 1817 map by Arrowsmith during his stay in Nagasaki (1823-1829), where foreigners from UK, Holland etc were permitted to stay in a limited area.

After he came back to Europe, he published many books on Japan including books on botanical species in Japan. He finally published the precise atlas of Japan "Atlas von Land- und Seekarten vom Japanischen Reiche Dai-Nippon" in 1851. It has been said that he didn't publish it for many years to protect the Japanese people who gave him the maps. In the map of Japan by von Siebold, Argonaut island was labeled as "Takasima (I. Argonaute)" and Dagelet island was labeled as "Matsusima (I. Dagelet)", which was the beginning of the name confusion of later years. (Liancourt Rocks were not drawn in the map, as the rocks had just been discovered 2 years before by France and UK had not discovered Hornet Rocks yet in 1851.)

Details of the maps can be seen at the Sophia University's homepage here: http://libknwlg.lib.sophia.ac.jp/mcenter/special/jpnplateind.html
Or visit here and click the fifth book:

But when I saw the 1817 map by Arrowsmith, I thought it was natural for him to give names Takeshima to Argonaut island and Matsushima to Dagelet island because von Siebold may have heard from Japanese people around him (possibly his Japanese wife Taki or Otakisan) about Japanese two islands called Takeshima and Matsushima (or he may have seen some traditional maps with the two islands) and there was this famous map showing two islands, Argonaut and Dagelet islands, in the Sea of Japan.

BTW, von Siebold also included a map of Korea in the atlas. (Please see the details at the homepage above) There is a writing at Ulleungdo "UrIjong to v.v Tsjor sankuk" (Ulleungdo and Usanguk?) in his map of Korea. It is obvious that he believed that Ulleungdo belonged to Korea while Takeshima (Takasima) and Matsushima (Matsusima) belonged to Japan.

6.7.08

Ulleungdo and Usan were visible from Korean peninsula

To follow is from 高麗史 (Vol.58, 地理 geography 3; 1451)


一云 干山武陵 本二島 相距不遠 風日清明則可望見

According to one theory, these two islands Usan and Mulleung (武陵) are not so distant and they are easily visible on fine days.

Korean government and pro-Korean scholars keep insisting that Usan in the sentence is Liancourt Rocks, and the text means Liancourt Rocks could be seen from Mulleung (Ulleungdo) on fine days. They interpreted it like this in order to impress that Korea knew Liancourt Rocks from the ancient times.

On the other hand, Japanese scholars have an opinion that it meant these two islands could be seen from Korean peninsula on fine days. They think that Usan in the text is not Liancourt Rocks.

Please look at the following map, introduced by a reader of this forum who has an ID of opp.
Please visit here to get the map in large size:
(Click the map)
It was called as " 江原道古地図(Kanwondo old map)" which was probably made in the end of Yi dynasty. There is a writing at the east of Korean peninsula, "鬱陵于山両島 天気清明蔚三両地登高皆見". This can be translated as follows:

Both of Ulleung and Usan islands are all visible from the highlands of 蔚珍・三陟 on fine days.

Of course, Liancourt Rocks can't be seen from Korean peninsula. So this may show that odds are in Japanese scholars' favour. Usan in the text was not Liancourt Rocks.

1894 British map of Japan

This map was published by Edward Stanford, Charing Cross, London, in 1894. Edward Stanford was the founder of Stanford's Ltd, now a duo of maps and book stores based in London and Bristol. With British colonial expansion pushing the demand for maps worldwide, and being the sole specialist of maps in London, the name of Stanford became prominent. His most accurate map of London in 1862, The Library Map of London, is still on sale today.

Now look at the islands in the Sea of Japan. There are three islands labeled as "Taka Shima", "Matsu Shima" and "Liancourt Rks.". "Taka Shima" is coloured in light brown which is the same colour as Korean peninsula, while "Matsu Shima" is in light purple which is the same as Oki islands, counties of Iwami, Idzumo and Hoki. Also please note a line drawn in red dots around "Matsu Shima". This line is the national border. UK in 1894 believed that "Taka Shima", obviously a phantom island called Argonaut island, was Korean territory while they believed "Matsu Shima" (Dagelet island) and "Liancourt Rks." were Japanese territory. This is another evidence that the world didn't think Liancourt Rocks to be Korean territory in the 1890's, just a while before the #41 Korean Edict which mentioned Seokdo was issued in 1900.

3.7.08

c1865 French map of Korea (Coree)

This is a map made by French missions to Korea, whcih was published in Paris in circa 1865. (Coree, par les Missionnaires de Coree de la Societe des Missions Etrangeres.)
There is a name of R.Hausermann, an engraver, at the left bottom of the map.
[This map is from the Osaka University Library.]

Please compare with the 1855 map, which depicted Ulleungdo (Oulangto) and Usan (Oosan) in traditional Korean way.

This map may be the basis of the 1880 map as the shape of the peninsula and islands are similar.


Sorry, I tried to make it possible for readers to click to enlarge the map but it didn't work well.
Please visit here to see the map in large size:

1944 - 1984 National Geographic Maps

To follow are the maps from the "National Geographic" homepage. Click the button to zoom, then click the area of the map you want to see and you will be able to see the details of the maps.
Ulleungdo was titled in Japanese pronunciation as "Utsuryo To" in 1944, and then changed to Korean name "Ullung Do [Dagelet]" in the 1952 and 1953 maps. In the map of 1960, there was the name of "Korea" in red beside the island.
On the other hand, Liancourt Rocks were kept labeled as "Take Shima [Liancourt Rcoks]" from the 1944 map until 1960 map. In the 1984 map of Japan, it was included in the map although the name was changed to "Tok Do (Liancourt Rocks)".
It seems that American people used to recognise Ulleungdo as Korean territory and Liancourt Rocks as Japanese territory even after the Peace Treaty.

Japan map 1944 with Asia and the pacific Ocean:
http://www.ngmapcollection.com/product.aspx?cid=1535&pid=15673

The Far East map 1952:
http://www.ngmapcollection.com/product.aspx?cid=1535&pid=15847

China Coast and Korea map 1953:
http://www.ngmapcollection.com/product.aspx?cid=1535&pid=15895

Japan and Korea map (1960):
http://www.ngmapcollection.com/product.aspx?cid=1535&pid=15990

Japan map 1984:
http://www.ngmapcollection.com/product.aspx?cid=1535&pid=15767

2.7.08

1855 French map of Korea (Coree)


This map was published in 1855 in Paris. This may have been made on the basis of information in 1846 as the credit says "d'Apres l'Original dressee par Andre Kim en 1846 et apportee" but anyway, it was made in the mid-19th century. There are two islands off Samtsek which were labeled as "Oulangto" (Ulleungdo) and "Ousan" (Usan). Although it didn't show longitudinal lines, the location of Oulangto (Ulleungdo) seems to be almost the same as the eastern edge of "Taimato" (Tsushima) which is located at 129 degree E - more western than true Ulleungdo is located.

By the way, Dagelet island (Ulleungdo) had been already discovered when this map was made - it was discovered by a French ship in 1787. Liancourt Rocks was yet to be discovered (if the information was given in 1846 - three years earlier than 1849 when Liancourt Rocks were discovered), but the rocks were discovered 6 years earlier than the publicartion year . So if the French mapmaker knew that "Oulangto" was Dagelet island, they should have written as "Oulangto (Dagelet Isl)" but they didn't. It seems that they thought these two islands off Korean east coast were different from Dagelet island. If these two islands were believed to be closer to Korean peninsula than Dagelet island, "Ousan" was not Liancourt Rocks as the latter were located at more eastern position than Dagelet island. And the shape of the island is different from Liancourt Rocks. This may have been another evidence to prove that Usan (Ousan) was not Liancourt Rocks.


Addendum: Please see also the map (1880) Gerry introduced here:

It says that the map in the 1880 was based on Father Kim Degeon's Carte de la Corée of 1846. (Is this 金大建's 朝鮮全圖, 1846?) I haven't a slightest idea if Father Kim Degeon and Andre Kim was the same person or not. The map in 1880 looks more accurate - it depicted Ulleungdo as "Oul-neung-to (Is. Dagelet)" and the shape of "Ou-san" looks like today's Jukdo. It seems to me that mapmakers noticed that Ulleungdo was Dagelet island in the period between 1855 and 1880.

Additional post:
I found the Carta de la Coree (1846) here - it looks almost the same as the 1855 map (above).

Carta de la Coree (1846):


And in 1865, the map was much improved. It looks more accurate than the 1855 map. Note that they labeled as "I. Dagelet" which is inclusive of both Ulleungdo and Usan (Ousan).

1877 Jpn Map of Ulleungdo

Below is a cutout of an 1877 Japanese map of Ulleungdo that shows Ulleungdo with two neighboring islands. The one island off the east shore is obviously present-day Jukdo (竹島), but the other island off the southern tip of Ulleungdo is unnamed. Is there a translation somewhere of the placenames and distances shown on this map? I would especially like to know what is written at the southern tip of Ulleungdo.

I think it is interesting that this map showed the islet off the southern tip of Ulleungdo as a neighboring islet rather than Gwaneumdo (觀音島) or any of the northern rocks. Western maps also seemed to emphasize the islet off Ulleungdo's southern-most tip, which was labeled as "Seal Point" on Western maps. Maybe this islet was more significant than people today realize? I wonder if it is still there, or has it been incorporated into some kind of breakwater? Someday I would like to get to Ulleungdo and check out this area of the island.

The cutout came from THIS MAP, which, itself, is a cutout.


1.7.08

1891 American map of Japan

This colour map of Japan was included in a cyclopedia set called "International Cyclopaedia" published in 1891. It was engraved and printed by the Matthews-Northrup Works of Buffalo, NY. Railroads are shown and there is an inset map of the Kurile islands.

Please take a look at the Sea of Japan - there are "TAKA SHIMA", "MATSU SHIMA" and "LIANCOURT RKS". Although "Taka Shima" and "Liancourt Rocks" look uncoloured, "Matsu Shima" (Ulleungdo) looks green, the same colour as Oki islands and Hoki county. (Korea is coloured in pink.)


So this maybe another evidence to show that USA recognised Matsu-Shima (Ulleungdo) to be Japanese territory which means they didn't think that Liancourt Rocks, which are located 92 km east of Ulleungdo, belonged to Korea at all in the 1890's.

30.6.08

1919 National Geographic Map of Korea

Below is a map of Korea from a July 1919 National Geographic article. The map shows Ulleungdo labeled as "Matsu Shima." Though the article, itself, has nothing to do with Liancourt Rocks, it is still well worth reading. Read the whole article in PDF form HERE. You will not regret it. (Double click on the map to enlarge it.)