Korean students only scream and yell "Dokdo is our land," but cannot explain why.

This Korean instructor is complaining that the Japanese are winning the international opinion war for their claim to "Dokdo" (Liancourt Rocks - Takeshima) because they can logically explain the reasons for their claim and are doing so in several different languages. He says that Korean students, on the other hand, only scream and yell "Dokdo is our land," but are unable to explain why. The instructor predicts the world will consider "Dokdo" to be Japanese territory within thirty years time.

What happens in Korea if you disagree with its Dokdo claim?

Today I clicked on a link that took me to the Dokdo Research Institute Web site where I decided to check out their Open Discussion Board. There I found a post HERE dated January 4, 2012. Here is the translation of that post:

The Usando shown on an old document is Jukdo?? 

http://blog.naver.com/royalty1234  

The Bulletin Board of this person's blog says that Dokdo is Japanese territory. If you go in and look at it, he claims that the Usando shown on an old document is Jukdo. He shows various materials to support his claim. The material he uses is wrong, and his claim is wrong. I urge to you refute them.

If you click on the link to the offending blog, you now get a message from the blog provider, Naver, that reads as follows:

This is a Closed Blog. Access to this blog has been restricted by request of the Korea Communications Standards Commission.

Old Korean documents show Usando (于山島 - 우산도) to be Ulleungdo's neighboring island of Jukdo (竹島 - 죽도), which is only about 2 kilometers off Ulleungdo's east shore. However, Koreans generally claim that "Usando" was the old name for "Dokdo" (Liancourt Rocks). Apparently, in Korea, one is not allowed to disagree with the general Korean claim.

The Lesson: "Don't use a Korea-based internet service provider to create a blog refuting Korea's claim to 'Dokdo' because opposing opinions are apparently not allowed."

The following are the screenshots of the bulletin board post on the Dokdo Research Institute Web site and of the message from Naver saying the blog is closed.

Japan Probe: "New Jersey Japanese School Wins Takeshima Lawsuit"

A lawsuit brought against a Japanese School in New Jersey for teaching that Takeshima (Dokdo) is Japanese territory has been dismissed. A Korean-American who did not like the school's using a Japanese Social Studies textbook that taught Takeshima (Dokdo) was Japanese territory filed a lawsuit against the school last year. You can read more about the lawsuit in English at "Japan Probe" HERE.

You can read the legal decision HERE.

Japanese readers can read about it in Sankei News:

「日本人学校が竹島で偏向教育」韓国系米国人の訴え棄却　米ニュージャージー州

A Korean translation can be read at the KJClub HERE by clicking on 韓国語で表示.

In the footnotes of her legal decision, the Judge wrote the following:

As a former civil mediator, it would certainly be tempting to suggest that this historic Asian-Pacific dispute, which apparently remains the cause of wide-ranging emotions and politics on both sides, be settled through a designation of one islet to each country. Clearly, if the solution were that simple, it would have occurred before today.

1869? Map of Korea - "東國八域山川一綂全圖." Shows Ulleungdo with a neighboring island labeled "Udo" (于島)

The following Korean map is entitled "Dongguk Pal Yeok San Cheon Il Tong Jeondo" (東國八域山川一綂全圖), which means "Complete Map of All Eight Regions of Mountains and Streams of the Eastern Country." The map is believed to have been made in 1869 and is houseed in the Library of Congress of the United States. LINK

One of the interesting things about the map is that it shows the island of Ulleungdo (鬱陵島 - 울릉도) with a neighboring island labeled "Udo" (于島 - 우도), which was one of the old names for Ulleungdo's neighboring island of Jukdo (竹島 - 죽도), a small island just two kilometers off Ulleungdo's east shore.

Later 1800s - "Takeshima Map Explanation" (竹島圖說) Kensaku Kanamori - "文鳳堂雑纂"

The following comes from a Japanese text entitled "A Compilation of Topics by Bun Ho Do, Vol. 16" (文鳳堂雑纂 - 十六), which seems to have been a volume compiled sometime before 1886 by  Kensaku Kanamori (金森謙建策).

One reason I am posting this text is that I think it was mentioned in an 1876 letter entitled "Concerning Matsushima 2," by Watanabe Kouki (渡辺洪基), who was Director of the Bureau of Documents in Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs at the time. Mr. Watanabe was trying to determine if the Japanese name Matsushima (松島) was being used to refer to the Korean island of Ulleungdo (鬱陵島) or to some other island. Another reason I am posting it is that it seems like a very interesting text.

Traditionally, the name "Matsushima" or "Oki's Matsushima" was used by the Japanese to refer to Liancourt Rocks, but Mr. Watanabe suspected that it was also being used to refer to Ulleungdo. In the text, Ulleungdo is referred to as "Takeshima" (竹島) and Liancourt Rocks as "Oki Domain's Matsushima" (隠岐国の松島).

The following is the referrence to the Kensaku (金森謙) text from Mr. Watanabe's 1886 letter:

又金森謙ノ書ニ竹島周圍大凡十五里トアリ 

Also, in the text by Kensaku (金森謙), the circumference of Takeshima was written as 15 ri.

(Mr. Tanaka's Web site is the source of this text HERE.)

Takeshima Map Explanation (竹島圖說)  

In the text “ A Record of the Land of Japan” (日本風土記), “TA (他) KE (計) JI (甚) MA (麽) refers to Takeshima (竹島).   

The family of Kitazono (北園子家), a retired retainer of this Domain, has a text of his entitled “Takeshima Map Explanation” (竹島圖說), in which this family’s ancestor, Mr. Tsuuan, (通葊氏) recorded old stories during the Hohreki Era (1751 – 1764) that were passed down among the people of Inshu (因州). So little is known about it/them that this book can, indeed, be called a treasure.  

I also recorded the story of an oarsman from Iwami (石見). His name was Chozo ((長蔵), from the village of Hamada (濱田). He still lives in Bittyu Province (備中), but is temporarily staying in the town of Obara/Kobara (小原街). (This town may have been what is now the neighborhood of Obara (小原町) in the village of Kasubuchi (粕淵村) in the Ohchi District of Iwami Province (石見囯.)  

These stories are passed down, but I have added to them. I hope this helps those interested in learning about the geography of Takeshima.  

Written by Kanamori Ken Kensaku (金森謙建策　題)  

As for the map of the island, I have made a copy and attached it.  

Someone told me that an essay by Itoh Tohgai (伊東涯) said that the Island of Jikuro (軸羅島) in the Book of Sui(隋書) must be this Takeshima. According to the essay, the circumference (of the island) was 40 ri. I believe his view is probably correct.  

竹島図説　 

日本風土記　他計甚麼　竹島云々 

予藩之隠士北园子家、有一書在焉　名曰、竹嶋図説
此其家祖、通葊氏者、宝暦年間 甞所傳記　于因人某而
世間知之殆鮮矣　実可謂一珍書也。 

予、復筆, 石之一撑夫　[名長蔵、濱田人也、時未(時來)于備、寓于小原街]
口碑之説而増補於斯。蓋爲使 有志之人 竹島地理亦識焉而耳矣。 

　　　　　　　　　　　　　　金森謙建策　題  

島図ハ、別ニ一葉ヲ作テ茲ニ附ス。○或ル人、予ニ謂テ曰、「伊東涯ガ随筆ニ云。『隋書ニ所謂「軸羅島」ハ、蓋、此竹島ナラン』ト。其説ニハ、周囲四十里ト云リ。」謙按ニ、此説、恐ハ是ナラン。
.

There is an island called Takeshima about forty ri to the north of the west island of Oki Province’s Matsushima (隠岐國松島ノ西島). (West Island is part of Matsushima and is called “Next Island” by the locals.) The island borders on Japan and is next to Korea. 

They say that it is about forty ri by sea from Takeshima to Korea. This is based on the story of an old man who in 1724, the 9th year of Kyoho (亨保), testified that he had previously traveled to the island several times. When asked he said, “The distance from the village of Mitsuyanagi (三柳) of Hamanome (濱野目) in Aimi County (會見郡) of Houki Province (伯州) to Oki’s Dogo Island (隠岐ノ後島) is between 35 and 36 ri. Using this distance one can guess the distance from Takeshima to the mountains of Korea to be about 40 ri since it seems a bit farther. I suspect that “mountains of Korea” was referring to the mountains of Ulleungdo. The island is triangular in shape and has a circumference of about 15 ri. (It says 15 ri, but that is a rough measurement.)

According to the oarsman (from Iwami), the length from east to west is longer than the length from north to south. Also, there is so much bamboo and so many trees that there are many places that are difficult to enter very far. 

There are many products on this strange island. Near the southeast corner of the island is a place everyone calls Old Port Osaka (古大坂浦), where there is a large bamboo grove with bamboo as large as 2 feet in circumference. To the west of this port is Port Hamada (濱田浦). In between there are two small streams. The source is a waterfall (taki) in the mountains that flows out and joining a river to the east before splitting into three streams that flow into the sea. Among these three streams the middle one is said to have many "sweet fish" (ayu). (The Chinese for ayu is 香魚.)

Also, a little to the west of Port Hamada (濱田浦) is Port Take (竹浦), which is a convenient place to moor boats. However, when the southern wind is servere, it is hard to keep ships tied, so most people house their boats on shore. To the west of this port is a large river that flows into the sea. To the west of the river is a small stream that flows into the river. To the west of that is an island, the name of which I still do not know. To the west of the island is a small stream which seems to be a source of the river to the east instead of a waterfall in the mountains.

To the west of the small stream is Port Northland (北国浦), and a little north of there is Port Willow (柳浦). A little north of Port Willow (柳浦) is another stream, which is fed by a small stream to the east, increasing its size.

隠岐國松島ノ西島(松島ノ一小屬ナリ島土俗呼テ次島ト做ス)ヨリ海上道規凡四十里許リ北方ニ一島アリ名テ竹島ト曰フ 此ノ島日本ニ接シ朝鮮 (竹島ヨリ朝鮮ヘ海上道規四十里許ト云此說ハ享保九年昔屢島セル一老叟ニ詰問セラレト其答伯州會見郡濱野目三柳村ヨリ隱岐ノ後島ヘ三十五六里アリ是遠見ノ考ヲ以テ竹島ヨリ朝鮮山ヲ見ハ少ク遠ク見エルハ凡四十里許カト云リ謙按ニ那朝鮮ト山ルハ恐ハ朝鮮ノ鬱陵山ナラン)ニ隣シ地形三角ニシテ周囲凡ソ十五里許リ (是十五里卜云モ只其大概ヲ云丿ミ)

撑夫ノ言ニ、「東西、特に長袤、果たして甚庅、知るべからず」且、竹木尤モ繁茂、人ヲシテ敢テ入可ラシメサルノ地、往々少ナカラスト。産物尤モ多キ一奇島ナリ。島ノ東南辺ヲ、捴テ古大坂浦ト曰フ。 此ノ辺ハ、多クハ大竹薮ニシテ、極テ大ナルハ周囲（メグリ）二尺許ト云リ。此ノ浦西島ヲ濱田浦ト曰フ。此ノ中間ニ小流アリ。其ノ水原ハ、山中ノ瀑布（タキ）ヨリ出テ、東方ノ大河ニ流ヲ合テ、大小三岐ニ分レ、流テ海ニ入ル。但シ、中条ノ河水ニハ年魚（アユ）ヲ生スルコト尤モ多シトス。（アユは漢名、香魚である。)

又、此ノ濱田浦ノ少シ西方ヲ竹浦ト名ク。舟ヲ寄ルニ便ナル所ナリ。然レドモ、南風劇キトキハ繋キ難キカ故、大抵、居舟（スヘフネ）ニ做シ置ナリ。此ノ浦ノ西方ニ大河一条アリテ流テ海ニ入ル。此大河ノ西方ニ、又小流一条アリ。合シテ斯ニナガル。此ノ西ニ又一島アリ。未其名ヲ知ラス。此島ノ西方ニ小川一条アリ。此小川モ東方ノ大河ト共ニ、其水原ハ、那ノ山中ノ瀑布ニ因ラサルナリ。

此小川ノ西島ヲ北国浦ト名ケ、微シ北ヲ柳浦トイフ。此柳浦ノ稍（ヤヤ）北方ニ、又一流アリ。此ハ、那東方ノ小川二流ノ水原ニシテ、頗ル大ナリトス。此流水ノ...

The northern bank of this stream connects to a field of reeds. Far to the east of there is an area called Port Osaka (大坂浦).

Also, in the center of the island, in the mountains a little to the east of the waterfall, there is a spring with clear water that tastes sweet. It is said that it produces about two 升 per day. I suspect it is a similar to so-called "sugar-sweetened water" (甘露水).

"It is about 140 ri by ship from Yonago in Houki Province (伯州米子) to Takeshima. You can sail from Yonago to Izumo (出雲) and then on past Oki’s Matsushima (隠岐丿松島) to reach Takeshima. However, it is said that it is about 60 ri by ship from Oki’s Fukushima (福島), also called Fukuura (福浦), to Matsushima, and then about 40 ri from Matsushima to Takeshima. Moreover, it is about 40 ri from Takeshima on to Korea."

The above account was the response from Yonago residents Kyuemon Oya (大谷九右衛) and Ichibee Murakawa (村川市兵衛) to a 1724 inquiry from the Shogunate."

...北辺ニ続テ葦原アリ。斯レヨリ頗ル東ニヨル処ニ大坂浦ト云フ地アリ。

又、島ノ中央、瀑布ヨリ僅ニ東ニ当ル山中ニ一井アリ。其水清ク、味甘美ナリ。一日ニ漸、二●（舛の異体字？）許リ、湧出シ来ルト云リ。按謙ニ、所謂甘露水ノ类欤。

伯州米子ヨリ竹島マテ海上道規百六十里許アリ 米子ヨリ出雲ヘ出隠岐ノ松島ヲ歴テ竹島ニ至ルナリ 但隠岐ノ福島ヨリ松島マテ海上道規六十里許松島ヨリ竹島マテ四十里許ト云也以上ノ諸説ハ享保九申辰年官府江府ノ叩問ニ依テ米子ノ市人大谷九右衛門村川市兵衛カ貴答ノ上書ニ原ケリ.

People call this island Takeshima, which is 70 ri from Oki Province. It's circumference is about 16 ri. It has many streams. 

自隱岐國七十里而有此嶋俗号竹島是也 嶌之廽リ大槩十六里 百大河 

Japanese know that Takeshima is located in the sea north of Oki Province. A fisherman from Houki Province (伯耆州) first started fishing there. This island is very near Korea, but previously Koreans did not know of the island. About 3 ri north of this island is another island where there are a great many superior quality abalone. Therefore, it is said that Koreans are sent to the island once every 3 to 5 years to harvest the abalone. At one time Koreans did not know of Takeshima, but in the spring of 1692, they drifted to the island and learned of it for the first time.  

This story is accurate since it was given as testimony by Houki Province fishermen and others at hearing in April 1693.

This is a summary of the island's products: Grasses, trees, sand, and rocks

日本人、隠岐ノ北海ニ竹島アルコトヲ知テ、魚猟ヲ創メシハ伯州ノ一漁父ナリ。是、甚タ朝鮮ニ隣スレトモ、昔時ハ、鮮人却テ之ヲ知ラス。此島ノ以北三里許ニ亦タ一島アリテ、上好ノ蚫最多シ。因テ朝鮮ヨリ三五年二一回、漁人ヲ遣テ蚫ヲ取ラシムト云リ。彼、曾、此竹島ヲ知ラサリシニ、我元禄五年ノ春、此島ニ漂流シテ始メテ竹島アルコトヲ知ルナリ。

此説ハ、元禄六年四月、伯州ノ漁夫等カ訴訟ノ状態ニ由テ粲然タル所タリ。 

島産略抄 

草木沙石ニハ

Pages 8 and 9

.... 1. We set sail from Yonago (米子) on February 11 in the 5th year of Genroku (1692) and arrived at Port Fuku (隠岐國 福浦) in Oki Province on the last day of the month. We set sail from Port Fuku on March 24 and landed at Takeshima’s Ika Island (竹島ノイカ島) at about 8 o’clock in the morning on the 26th. We noticed that someone had been fishing there. We had never seen this before.

On the morning of the 27th, on our way to the island’s Port Hamada (濱田浦), we saw two foreign ships. One was anchored and the other was floating. We saw about thirty foreigners on the floating vessel, which was about 8 to 9 ken (間) from us as we passed and turned toward Port Osaka (大坂浦). One man was on shore. He boarded a small boat and came to the side of our ship. 

When we asked, he answered he came from the Korean village of “Kawaten” (カワテレカワラ). He spoke our language well as if he was an interpreter. Then when we demanded to know why they were harvesting the abalone, he said, “We did not originally plan to harvest abalone on this island. There is an island to the north of here where there is lots of good quality abalone. We travel to that island once every three years by the order of the Korean king. This year we were again headed for that island, but met an ill wind that caused us to drift here."

Then we said,  "This is Takeshima, and Japanese have been coming here to harvest abalone since long ago, so you must quickly leave." He said the storm they met had completely destroyed their ship and that they would leave as soon as they repaired it, but they did not seem to be in a hurry to leave.

 When we we arrived, we first checked the hut we had previously built. (We kept boats, fishing gear, and other equipment there.)

元禄五年、春二月十有一日、例年ノ如ク米子ヨリ出帆シテ隠岐國福浦ニ著シ、同三月廿四日、福ウラヲ出帆シテ、同月廿六日、朝五時、竹島ノイカ島ト云処ニ着ス。是時、初メテ異邦ノ人、魚猟スルヲ見タリ。蓋、先之、未タ嘗テ見サル処ナリ。翌廿七日、我舟ヲ同島ノ濱田浦ニマハシシトスル海路ニ於テ、又異人舟二艘ヲ見タリ。但、一艘ハ居船ニシ、一艘ハ浮ヘテ、異国人三十人許、之レニ乗セリ。我舟ヲ八九間隔テ、大阪浦ニ廻ル。其人員ニ属スルモノカ一人、陸ニ遣リ居タルカ、忽チ小舟ニ乗シテ我近傍ニ来ル。因テ、之ニ問フニ、朝鮮ノ「カワテンカハラ」の人氏ト答フ。但、此人ハ象胥（ツウジ）ニ似テ、能ク我カ国語ニ通セリ。而シテ那ノ蚫猟ノ故ヲ詰ルニ、彼答ニ曰、原ヨリ此島ニ蚫ヲ猟スルノ意ナシ。然トモ此島ノ以北ニ一島アリテ、上好ノ蚫最多シ。是故ニ、吾儕朝鮮國王ノ命ヲ奉シテ、三年毎ニ一回、彼島ニ渡レリ。当年モ又、那島ニ渡リ、帰帆の路、難風ニ逢ヒ、不計此島（竹シマ）ニ漂泊スト云。尓時、我輩曰、此竹鳥ハ昔時ヨリ、日本人蚫猟を做シ来レル処ナレハ、速ニ出帆スヘシト云ハ、彼カ答ニ、難風ニ邁ヒ、舟皆損坏セルカ故ニ、之ヲ造補シテ後去ルヘシト説ケドモ、其実ハ急ニ退クヘキノ状態ニ非ス。我輩乃上陸シテ嘗テ築造セル小屋（猟船猟具其外雑具ヲ置）

We found that eight boats were missing. We asked the interpreter about this. He said that they had been sent to the other inlets. Furthermore, we very much wanted to go ashore, but there were so many in their group and so few in ours that we did not dare to try it.

Therefore, we departed Takeshima at 7 o'clock in the evening of March 21. However, we gathered  some shewered abalone, a Korean hat, a fermented soybean cake,  and some miso noodles as evidence we had traveled to the island. On April 1st, we arrived at Hamada (濱田 in Iwami (石州), stopped by Kumotsu (雲津) in Izumo (雲州), and returned to Yonago (米子) in Hoki Province (伯州) at 7  o'clock on the 5th day of the same month.

In the last part of February in the 6th year of Genroku (1693), we again set sail from Yonago and arrived at Takeshima without incident on April 17. However, just like the year before, a group of Koreans had arrived and were fishing at will, hindering us, occasionally using rude language, and being disruptive.

We had no choice but to take their leader and two or three of his companions on board our ship. We set sail from Takeshima on the 18th of April and returned on the 28th of the same month to Yonago, where we explained the situation to lord of Hoki Province.

ヲ検査スルニ、猟船八艘ヲ失ヘリ。由テ、之ヲ那ノ象胥ニ質セハ、皆浦々へ廻ハセリト答フ。加之、我舟ヲ居ヘント強レトモ、彼ハ衆、我ハ寡、衆寡固ヨリ敵スヘカラス。恐懼ノ情ナキコト能ハス。故ヲ以テ、三月（元禄五年三月）廿一日晩、七ツ時、竹島ヨリ出帆セリ。但、串蚫（少許）、笠（一个）、頭巾（一个）、味噌麺（一丸）ヲ携ヘ帰レリ。是ハ這回（コノタビ）ノ渡島ノ証ト做シカ為ノミ。四月朔、石州濱田ニ帰リ、雲州雲津ヲ経テ、同月五日七時、伯州米子ニ帰着セリ。 

翌元禄六年癸酉年、春二月下旬、再ヒ米子ヲ出帆シテ、夏四月十七日未刻、竹島ニ着セリ。然ルニ、昨年ノ如ク、朝鮮人等専ラ魚猟シテ我ヲ妨ケ、動モスレハ不軌ノ語言ヲ放ツテ和平ナラス。止ムコトヲ得ス、其中ノ長者一名ト火伴人両三輩を延ヒテ我舟ニ入レ、同月十八日竹島ヨリ出帆シテ、同廿八日米子へ帰リ、其由ヲ國候（松平伯州）へ訴フ。 國候、亦、之ヲ御勘定頭、松平美濃守殿へ達セラル。因テ台命ヲ下シテ、那ノ一夥ノ人員ヲ江都ヘ召レ、審ニ諸件ヲ正サセ玉ヒ、時ニ日本人ト朝鮮人トノ渡島ハ、時候ヲ異ニセルニ非スヤ、ト尋ネラレシカハ、右一夥ノ答ニ「我等ハ毎歳春二三月ノ比、渡島シ、七月上旬帰帆ノ節、猟舟猟具等ヲ小屋ニ蔵メ置、翌年渡島ノ斯マデ毫モ差違ナカリシニ、去ル元禄五年ヨリ、小屋ヲ発キ、肆ママニ器械ヲ奪ヒ、倨然トシテ居住スルノ模様

Years before, while Matsudaira Shintaro (松平新太郎) reigned Inshu and Hakushu (因伯両州), Ichibee Murakawa (村川市兵衛) and Oya Jinkichi (大谷甚吉), merchants from Yonago in Hakushu, went to Takeshima (Ulleungdo) to fish and continue to do so today. We have heard that the Shogun (Tokugawa Tsunayoshi) now prohibits voyages to Takeshima. His intention must be kept in mind. We humbly convey this to you.  

28 January 1696

Tsuchiya Masanao, Lord of Sagami (土屋政直相模守)
Toda Tadamasa, Lord of Yamashiro (戸田忠昌山城守)
Abe Masatake, Lord of Bungo (阿部正武豊後守)
Okubo Tadatomo, Lord of Kaga (大久保忠朝加賀守)
Matsudaira Suketoshi, Lord of Hoki (松平資俊伯耆守)

ニ見シハ、全ク此年、朝鮮人創メテ竹島ヲ捜出セシニ疑ヒナシ」ト云リ。尚且、之ニ依テ、魚猟難為之由、屡、愁訴ニ及ヘリ。後、元禄九年丙子年、正月廿八日、月番御老中、戸田山城守殿、奉書ヲ下サル。其文ニ曰、先年、松平新太郎、因伯両州領知之節、相伺窺之、伯州米子町人、村川市兵衛、大谷甚吉、至今、入竹島雖為漁猟。向後、入島之義、制禁可申付旨、被仰出。可存其趣。 恐惶謹言

元禄九年子正月廿八日  

土屋相模守在判 

戸田山城守　〃
阿部豊後守　〃
大久保加賀守　〃

松平伯耆守 殿

此歳竹島入猟ヲ禁セラレテヨリ元禄十一年丑秋米
子ノ市人村川市兵衛江戸ニ出テ愁訴ニ及ヘリ 尓
後享保九甲辰年江府ヨリ因州家へ　台問アリ
但米子ハ荒尾但馬カ食邑ナレハ同氏ヘ令シテ之ヲ正
レシ時彼両商ヨリ呈スル所ノ書ヲ謄写シテ池田豊後
（因州ノ大夫）ヨリ我藩ニ贈レリ 後宝暦年間因州ノ使者

来テ清泰院(宰相忠雄卿ノ墳墓アリ)ヘ寓スル時就テ之ヲ問ニ其所説恰符節ヲ合カ如シ毫モ差違スル所ナシ由テ今之ヲ筆乄予家ニ傳フト云

竹島図説　了

Toda Takayoshi's (戶田敬義) pre-1876 Map of Ulleungdo - Map A

The following map is one of three maps of "Takeshima" (Ulleungdo) obtained by Toda Takayoshi (戶田敬義) in 1876 or earlier. Another of his maps can be seen HERE. I am calling them Map A and Map B. This Map A looks a little more accurate than Map B. I do not know what happened to his third map.

One of his maps was mentioned in an 1876 letter entitled "Concerning Matsushma 2," which was written by Watanabe Kouki (渡辺洪基), the Director of the Bureau of Documents in Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs at the time. In the letter, Mr. Watanabe said that Toda Takayoshi's survey map showed the circumference of "Takeshima" (Ulleungdo) to be about 23 ri, a measure that was calculated by adding up all the measurements of the ins and outs of the shoreline on the map. The reference to the map was as follows:

又戶田敬義ノ圖私船ノ測量ヲ總計スレハ二十三里餘トナル[尤曲屈出入ヲ合セ沿岸]

Also, if you calculate all the survey measurements on Toda Takayoshi's private ship survey map, they add up to about 23 ri. (That measure includes all the ins and outs of the shoreline.)

I posting the map to give people an opportunity to look at it and to comment on it. I will modify the post later after reading the comments and studying the map myself, including trying to determine the circumference of the island. It looks like an interesting map. You can go to the source of the map at Mr. Tanaka's Web site HERE to find a much larger version.

I wonder what happened to Mr. Toda Takayoshi's third map of Ulleungdo.

Toda Takayoshi's (戶田敬義) pre-1876 Map of Ulleungdo - Map B

The following map, entitled "Map of Takeshima" (竹嶌之圖), is one of three maps of "Takeshima" (Ulleungdo) obtained by Toda Takayoshi (戶田敬義) in 1876 or earlier. I only know of two of them, which I will call Map A and Map B. This is Map B, and my post on Map A can be found HERE. You can go to the source of Map B at Mr. Tanaka's Web site HERE to find a much larger version of the map.

One of his maps was mentioned in an 1876 letter entitled "Concerning Matsushma 2," which was written by Watanabe Kouki (渡辺洪基), the Director of the Bureau of Documents in Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs at the time. In the letter, Mr. Watanabe said that Toda Takayoshi's  survey map showed the circumference of "Takeshima" (Ulleungdo) to be about 23 ri, a measure that was calculated by adding up all the measurements of the ins and outs of the shoreline on the map. He also said the island in the south corner of the map was probably Uindo (于人島), which was very probably a misspelling of Usando (于山島).

The reference to the map in Mr. Watanabe's letter was as follows:

又戶田敬義ノ圖私船ノ測量ヲ總計スレハ二十三里餘トナル[尤曲屈出入ヲ合セ沿岸] 

Moreover, it you add up all the measurements done by Toda Takayoshi (戶田敬義) on his map they total about 23 ri. (That includes all the ins and outs of the shoreline.) That circumference is more than just a little different than that of Matsushima, or Dagelet. On the south corner of the map is drawn an island that has a circumference of about 1.5 ri. The island is probably Uindo (于人島). 

1861 Royal Atas - "China and Japan"

The following map, entitled "China and Japan," is from the 1861 (MDCCCLXI) edition of "The Royal Atlas of Modern Geography," by Alexander Keith Johnston, the Geographer to the Queen of Scotland. The map shows the Korean island of Ulleungdo in the Sea of Japan labeled as "Dagelet or Matsusima." It also shows to the northwest of Ulleungdo the non-existent island of Argonaut, which was the result of a mismapping of Ulleungdo by the British ship Argonaut in 1789.

The reason I am posting the map is that it was mentioned in an 1876 letter written by Watanabe Kouki (渡辺洪基), who was Director of the Bureau of Documents in Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs at the time. Mr. Watanabe was researching the location of Dagelet Island, which was the Western name for Korea's Ulleungdo Island, and he used this map as an example of Western maps that showed Dagelet Island at the coordinates 37 degrees 25 minutes N. latitude and 130 degrees 56 minutes E. longitude.

 In his letter, which was entitled "Concerning Matsushima 2," Mr. Watanabe referred to the map in the following way:

英ノロヤールアトラス
Britain's "Royal Atlas"

Mr. Watanabe wanted to confirm the location of Dagelet Island because he suspected the Japanese name "Matsushima" (松島) was being used together with "Dagelet" to refer to Korea's Ulleungdo Island. Traditionally, the name "Matsushima," or "Oki's Matsushima," was used to refer to Liancourt Rocks, which Mr. Watanabe believed to be Japanese territory.

1873 British Nautical Chart of Japan and Korea

The following nautical chart entitled "Preliminary Chart of Japan Nipon, Kiusiu & Sikok and Part of the Korea" was issued by the British Navy's Hydrographic Office in 1873 and was made from British and foreign government surveys done up to 1870. The chart shows Korea's island of Ulleungdo labeled as "Matu sima" with "Dagelet I." in parenthesis. It also shows Liancourt Rocks labeled as "Liancourt Rks.," "Hornet Is.," and "Menelai and Olivutsa." The chart also shows the non-existent island of Argonaut drawn with a dotted line and labeled as "Take sima or Argonaut P.D." The "PD" next to Argonaut means "Position Doubtful."

The reason I am posting the chart  is that it was mentioned in an 1876 letter written by Watanabe Kouki (渡辺洪基), who was Director of the Bureau of Documents in Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs at the time. Mr. Watanabe was researching the location of Dagelet Island, which was the Western name for Korea's Ulleungdo Island, and he used this map as an example of Western maps that showed Dagelet Island at the coordinates 37 degrees 25 minutes N. latitude and 130 degrees 56 minutes E. longitude.

In his letter entitled "Second Opinion on Matsushima," Mr. Watanabe referred to the map in the following way:

If we look at Western texts, the British “Imperial Gazetteer” says that Dagelet Island (pronounced as “Dazera”),  or Matsushima, is an island in the Sea of Japan that is situated between the Japanese Archipelago and the Korean Peninsula. Its northwest corner is at 137 degrees (should read “37 degrees”) 25 minutes north latitude and 130 degrees 56 minutes east longitude (Greenwich means). It was named by La Pérouse in 1787. It has a coastline of sheer cliffs and is approximately 9 ri around. It is covered by dense forest up to its highest point.

Also, “Lippincott’s Pronouncing Gazetteer of the World”  says that Dagelet is a small island in the Sea of Japan that is exactly between Japan and Korea. It has a circumference of 8 ri and is positioned at 37 degrees 25 minutes north latitude and 130 degrees 56 minutes east longitude. If you look this up on a map, the location of the island labeled as Dagelet, or Matsushima, on the British Navy’s navigational chart seems to be at the same position as that in both books.

Traditionally, the name "Matsushima," or "Oki's Matsushima," was used by the Japanese to refer to Liancourt Rocks, which Mr. Watanabe believed were Japanese territory, and the name "Takeshima" was traditionally used by the Japanese to refer to Ulleungdo. However, Mr. Watanabe suspected that the name "Matsushima" was now also being used to refer to Ulleungdo, a suspicion the following British navigational chart seems to bear out. Since the name "Takeshima" had always appeared to the west of  "Matsushima" on old Japanese maps, people must have assumed the non-existent island of Argonaut was Takeshima, Korea's Ulleungdo. Therefore, since the real Ulleungdo was now labeled Matsushima, many Japanese and others believed it to be Japanese territory.